India pale ale (IPA) is third on the list of most popular beer styles in America. I would be willing to wager that it's the top pick of craft beer drinkers in the Twin Cities. We do love our hops, and these bitter brews are where they see their ultimate expression. India pale ales brim with the resinous, spicy and juicy citrus flavors of this vine-grown flower.
The copper color of India pale ale isn't what most people accustomed to light-yellow lagers would consider pale. I've even heard them described as dark. The pallid designation goes back to an earlier time when amber was a shade lighter than the brown and black beers that were more common.
Now two new iterations of the style — one black and one white — are stretching the concept of pale even further.
Black IPA presents a dilemma. How can something be both black and pale? This has led to a bicoastal competition for naming rights. Some call it Cascadian dark ale, referencing Washington's Cascade River Valley, where they say it was invented. Others argue for an East Coast origination and call it simply American black ale.
Whichever name you prefer, black IPAs are typically American-style India pale ales with a measure of roasted malt added to give them color. This results in a dark-hued, bitter brew that features a tantalizing blend of chocolate and citrus flavors. The roasty character of the dark malts ranges from subtle to relatively intense.
There are several good Minnesota-made options to try:
Douglas Cascadian Dark Ale is a limited release beer available right now from Steel Toe Brewing Co. It's a layered and complex brew that presents a definite IPA-like profile. Hops lead the way with aggressive bitterness and juicy tangerine and melon notes. Roasted malts stay mostly in the background with dry, chocolaty flavors reminiscent of Oreo cookies.
The full-bodied Midnight Ryder from Indeed Brewing Co. verges on being a hopped-up porter or stout. Leaning heavily on roasted malt, its bittersweet chocolate and slightly acrid coffee flavors nearly overwhelm the hoppy citrus and pine. The beer might leave a ponderous impression were it not for the high level of bitterness and semi-dry finish.