Michael Bay's "13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi" might not turn out to be the biggest film of 2016, but it could prove the most controversial. The studio released a two-and-a-half-minute trailer last week, and already critics are denouncing what little they've seen.
Bay's gaudy, implausible popcorn movies — the "Transformer" series, for instance — are often derided as "Bayhem." But this time the director is engaging a more serious theme, the 2012 attack on two U.S. compounds in Benghazi, Libya, that led to the deaths of four Americans, including Ambassador Christopher Stevens.
Given the subject matter, Deadline.com was probably on the money in its whimsical description of "13 Hours" as "a film whose topic is sure to make holiday dinners civil, polite affairs." The book on which the film is based, however, expressly disclaims any ideological intentions. So does Bay.
Not everyone is buying the disclaimers. The trailer has been dissected with the micrometric exactitude usually reserved for early looks at sci-fi franchises being taken over by J.J. Abrams.
Certainly Max Fisher of Vox seems to have made up his mind about "13 Hours" already: "Based on the trailer, it appears that Bay's movie will attempt to squeeze and contort the painful events of Benghazi into a neat and emotionally satisfying narrative: Brave American military heroes must overcome cowardly suits and shoot a bunch of bad guys so that they may save the day."
Fisher worries that the film will do for Benghazi what he seems to think Kathryn Bigelow's "Zero Dark Thirty" did for torture — sell people a false narrative:
"Americans care about what really happened in Benghazi, and they should: It was a significant event for U.S. foreign policy and U.S. politics. But it's been confused by three years of partisan spin, mud fights and conspiracy theories. Americans have to sort through a lot of noise to get to the truth."
Fisher is hardly alone in his concerns. Here's Scott Mendelson, writing in Forbes: "I can only presume from Bay's politics ("The Island" was an "abortion = holocaust" parable, "Bad Boys II" cheerfully embraces the abuse of authority of its reckless cop heroes and the "Transformers" sequels are neocon fables) that it won't exactly be the Nation's favorite action picture."