Ask Eric: Opinionated wife distresses husband

Her criticism of their son-in-law is causing friction.

Chicago Tribune
May 20, 2025 at 8:59AM

Dear Eric: We are retired grandparents to 7-year-old twins who live close by. We are delighted to help with chauffeuring, grocery shopping or anything else needed by two very hard-working parents.

Today after dropping off groceries, my wife noted that the refrigerator, in her opinion, had an unpleasant odor and was very quick to share her opinion with my son-in-law. She is rather critical of many of his habits, and her opinions are not without merit. But my mother always told me, “less said, better mended.”

When I say to my wife, “too much mother-in-law,” she gets mad at me. Should I say something to mend this, or should I just go back to my corner?

Eric says: It’s a shame we can’t get rich off of people adding their two cents. But because no bank will accept opinions as currency, some change is warranted here.

Your son-in-law has to manage his relationship with you and your wife, so if he’s feeling chafed by her opinions, he’s got to learn how to say something. You’ve told your wife what you think. Now it’s fine to back off.

However, if you feel something needs to be mended in the larger relationship, it’s fine to talk it through with your daughter and her husband, but loop in your wife first. This way it doesn’t seem to her like you’re talking behind her back.

Tell her, “I’m uncomfortable with the way our relationship is playing out with our son-in-law. I’m going to talk to both of them about ways that they can feel better supported. You can come along if you want, but this is just for listening and for learning.”

Sometimes we just need to be heard and understood.

Party crashers

Dear Eric: I read the letter from the person whose nephew planned his wedding on the same weekend as the letter writer’s mother’s 100th birthday. I just have to share this with you.

My husband and I have been happily married for 51 years. Coming from working-class families, we paid for our wedding ourselves.

My husband’s cousin also was engaged. They eloped on the same day we got married. We were at our reception, sitting down at the head table, when her mother, my husband’s aunt, came up and asked us to delay the meal until they arrived.

I was really surprised, but I was not going to let this ruin our day. I politely said no because we had a schedule to keep. They arrived and made a big to-do. We didn’t let it ruin our day because we figured that our guests would see them for what they were. We had a grand time.

Eric says: Oh my! I’ve heard all kinds of money-saving tips for weddings, but crashing a reception takes the cake, literally. I’m glad you were such a good sport about it and didn’t let it diminish your joy.

Don’t run away

Dear Eric: You gave good, practical advice to the recently retired attorney whose friends “disappeared” after a dementia diagnosis. Here’s an additional perspective:

No one chooses to get dementia. Dementia visits one in 10 of us around retirement age, and one in three of us a couple decades thereafter. At this prevalence, each of us knows someone living with dementia, whether we realize it or not.

We all have the opportunity as family and friends to learn how to care for and be supportive of our loved ones with dementia. Perhaps those of us with healthy brains even have a social responsibility to do so. Friends worth keeping will not run away from but rather run toward those living with dementia. This typically starts with taking a short training course. Virtual sessions are available from the Dementia Society of America (dementiasociety.org).

Eric says: This perspective is so valuable.

Send questions to R. Eric Thomas at eric@askingeric.com or P.O. Box 22474, Philadelphia, PA 19110.

about the writer

about the writer

R. Eric Thomas

More from Lifestyle

See More
card image
SARAH RICE/The New York Times

Also, expect multiple celebrations and ceremonies to be held at unconventional venues.

card image
card image