Ask Amy: Married boyfriend splits family

December 22, 2023 at 1:55PM

Dear Amy: My sister "Kelly," who lives out of state, won't be joining us for Christmas because Mom said no when Kelly asked if she could bring her married boyfriend home to meet the family.

I am firmly in Mom's corner and am hurt and disappointed that Kelly is choosing him over family. Kelly says the situation is "complicated," but for me it's not actually that complicated. My morals can be flexible at times, but marriage is an absolute line in the sand.

Am I being too judgy? Do I have to be supportive? Kelly is bound to bring him home at some point. I have no idea how to act.

Amy says: Bringing your married squeeze home for the holidays isn't exactly the makings of a Hallmark Channel movie. Still, you are being judgy, but feeling (or fearing) harsh judgment is the eternal sisters' lament. In many families, scrutinizing and judging one another is part of the sister relationship.

Consider making a deliberate choice not to judge your sister. Perhaps you could deliver this sentiment as a holiday gift: "I'm not here to judge you. But Mom's not ready, and I'm not ready to meet this man. We'll miss you this year, but let's make sure to talk on Christmas Day."

Yes, you should be supportive of your sister as a person, but you are not required to support all of her choices.

Dear Amy: My husband and I got married later in life (when I was 49, he was 44). This is his second marriage. We have struggled a bit with finances because I came into the marriage with much more, financially, so after a few years we decided to open a joint account.

I was excited to begin this commingling because it would establish more of a team approach to our future goals. But after three months I am realizing that he's spent nearly twice what he has contributed, and this is now creating more challenges.

He is refusing to tell me what he spent this money on and is making me feel irrational that I am concerned about this. He's refusing to come off of the joint account. He is threatening that my scrutiny marks the demise of our relationship. I'm worried because I know that finances can create the biggest issues in relationships, so I'm hoping for some guidance. Do you have any suggestions?

Amy says: You don't seem quite as alarmed as I believe you should be. Racking up huge bills, refusing to tell you where the money has gone, gaslighting you when you express concern and refusing to come off of this joint account are major red flags.

It is time for you to contact your bank (to figure out where this money is going) and a lawyer, to explore your spousal rights and responsibilities. I hope you'll act quickly.

Send questions to Amy Dickinson at askamy@amydickinson.com.

about the writer

about the writer

Amy Dickinson

More from No Section

See More
card image
Jerry Holt/The Minnesota Star Tribune

The closure of the Heritage Center comes as readers increasingly get their news online. The paper will now be printed in Iowa.