Ask Amy: Friend’s drinking is a troubling secret

Pretending to believe the lies has become too trying.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
June 5, 2024 at 1:00PM

Dear Amy: Two years ago, my friend “Kim” announced that she has cut alcohol out of her life after her brother died because of his alcoholism.

A couple of times I suspected she had been drinking. Last summer I took my suspicions to her sister-in-law, “Bea,” who confided that Kim is in group therapy for drinking, but that she went on a bender and got her second DUI. I was asked to keep this confidential.

Last month, Kim’s lies got bigger. When she did not return my text messages, I again reached out to Bea. I was told that Kim had to spend 30 days in jail for a drinking episode. Kim texted me within hours of being released, saying she had to care for her ailing dad out of town.

Because I was asked to keep this information confidential, I again chose to go along with Kim’s lies. Now she has informed me that she needs a ride each time we are together. She obviously has lost her driver’s license but refuses to admit it.

I completely understand why she would not want people to know, but I am caught in the crosshairs of her lies. I want to let Kim know that she has no need to lie to me anymore. It is not the drinking problem that bothers me. It’s the lying.

However, I do not want to go back on my word with Bea, who has asked me to keep the infornation quiet. If I approach Kim, it will be obvious how I found out. Do you have any advice on how to proceed without making matters worse?

Amy says: Kim has been lying to you. And you have been lying to her. You’ve trapped yourself by approaching a third party and then agreeing to keep this quiet.

Try a version of this: “Kim, I’ve suspected that you’ve relapsed a couple of times, and I want you to know that if that’s true, you can tell me the truth and count on my support. I know this is a really tough disease. No judgment from me. I will always support you in every way I can.”

If she continues to deny her drinking, don’t push. Being honest about her drinking will be a big part of supporting her sobriety, but she might not be there, yet.

Share the facts

Dear Amy: I am a relatively healthy 81-year-old retired university professor. I hike eight miles a day. But I recently was diagnosed with preliminary Alzheimer’s disease. I’ve told my wife and daughter about this, but no one else.

I am fully aware of my memory problems, but they are not yet obvious to others. When I meet someone and they say, “Hello, Sam,” I almost never know their name instantly. But most of the time it comes to me eventually.

I presume I will get worse with time. How do I handle revealing the underlying diagnosis to folks as time passes?

Amy says: There is no sturdy protocol for how to handle revealing your diagnosis, but I suggest that you should do this only at a time that feels right for you and in a way that reflects your strong intellect, healthy body and stout character.

Today I’m remembering my late Aunt Jean, who disclosed her diagnosis to family members all at once during our weekly diner breakfast, and she did so in a completely straightforward and good-humored way. Her candor set the tone for many honest conversations well into the future.

Amy Dickinson is stepping down at the end the month and will be replaced by R. Eric Thomas. Send him questions at eric@askingeric.com.

about the writer

about the writer

Amy Dickinson

See Moreicon