Dear Amy: Two years ago, my friend “Kim” announced that she has cut alcohol out of her life after her brother died because of his alcoholism.
A couple of times I suspected she had been drinking. Last summer I took my suspicions to her sister-in-law, “Bea,” who confided that Kim is in group therapy for drinking, but that she went on a bender and got her second DUI. I was asked to keep this confidential.
Last month, Kim’s lies got bigger. When she did not return my text messages, I again reached out to Bea. I was told that Kim had to spend 30 days in jail for a drinking episode. Kim texted me within hours of being released, saying she had to care for her ailing dad out of town.
Because I was asked to keep this information confidential, I again chose to go along with Kim’s lies. Now she has informed me that she needs a ride each time we are together. She obviously has lost her driver’s license but refuses to admit it.
I completely understand why she would not want people to know, but I am caught in the crosshairs of her lies. I want to let Kim know that she has no need to lie to me anymore. It is not the drinking problem that bothers me. It’s the lying.
However, I do not want to go back on my word with Bea, who has asked me to keep the infornation quiet. If I approach Kim, it will be obvious how I found out. Do you have any advice on how to proceed without making matters worse?
Amy says: Kim has been lying to you. And you have been lying to her. You’ve trapped yourself by approaching a third party and then agreeing to keep this quiet.
Try a version of this: “Kim, I’ve suspected that you’ve relapsed a couple of times, and I want you to know that if that’s true, you can tell me the truth and count on my support. I know this is a really tough disease. No judgment from me. I will always support you in every way I can.”