Dear Amy: My husband's narcissistic father died by suicide three months ago.
After spending 25 years of our adult life dealing with his childish, nasty, out-of-proportion reactions to our lifestyle and family values, we created boundaries for him within our family.
It infuriated him that he could not use money to get us to adore him. He wrote my husband out of his will and left his estate to my husband's siblings. This was a pain that you cannot know unless it is done to you.
Is it naive to think that his siblings would give up a percentage of their inheritance to make my husband whole and even things out? It is not about the monetary value of the inheritance — if offered a share, my husband would give his portion to charity — it is about doing what is natural as siblings.
How do we have a relationship with these people who continue their father's legacy of dangling money in exchange for adoration?
Amy says: Based on what you say, these siblings are not dangling money in front of you and your husband. They simply are choosing to keep money that was left to them.
I do not think it is "natural" for siblings to share an inheritance with an estranged family member, especially if your husband had exited from a relationship with their father. So yes, you are being naïve.
Presumably, these siblings endured their father's mental illness and suicide from a closer perspective than your husband did, and whether their motivation was a financial or filial one, they might feel that they've already paid dearly for every penny they've inherited.