A gathering of Eagle scouts

As the Boy Scouts of America strives to diversify, a St. Paul troop stands out for its proliferation of Eagle Scouts.

September 7, 2008 at 2:26AM
These four eagle scouts have been friends for a number of years through church, school and scouting activities. From left, Jacob Schwartz, Nate Knight, Albert Williams and Paul Ndayizeye.
Troop 96 of St. Paul has seven Eagle Scouts in the troop, a record number of African-Americans to be so designated in the same troop. These four Eagle Scouts have been friends for years through church, school and scouting. From left: Jacob Schwartz, Nate Knight, Albert Williams and Paul Ndayizeye. (Dml - Minneapolis Star Tribune S/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Ten years ago, Bill Butchee led his fledgling Boy Scout troop on a camping trip and ran into a more established troop.

"They asked us how many Eagle Scouts we had, and I said none," he recalled. But he and the other scout leaders had a vision that, one day, their St. Paul troop would produce an Eagle Scout.

Little did he know that the troop would go on to turn out a bumper crop.

Seven members of Troop 96, sponsored by St. Peter Claver Catholic Church, have become Eagle Scouts this year -- a rarity. The accomplishment is impressive given that only about 4 percent of scouts become Eagles, said Kent York, a spokesman for the Boy Scouts of America's Northern Star Council.

The new Eagles from Troop 96 also represent the most African-American scouts in a single troop from the council, which serves the Greater Twin Cities area and western Wisconsin, to attain scouting's highest rank in the same year.

The local milestone comes at a time when the Boy Scouts of America is doubling efforts to involve more kids of color in scouting. "When people think of scouting, they think of the stereotypical white, middle-class boy out in the woods," York said. It's an image the nearly-100-year-old organization is fighting to change as it tries to stay relevant to today's diverse youth.

In Maryland, the Baltimore-area Boy Scouts council has partnered with the local NAACP to recruit more scouts. In Houston and elsewhere, the scouts have started troops in which all members are from the same ethnic group.

Eric Moore, a spokesman for the Boy Scouts of America, said there are many reasons why there aren't more African-Americans involved in scouting.

"There are other types of programs and activities out there that compete for attention with youth today," he said. "Research tells us that particularly in the African-American community, the youth lean toward more sports-oriented things that are competitive in nature."

In the beginning, Troop 96 leaders had to fight the perception that scouting is a white thing.

"A lot of times African-American young men think that scouting is a white man's club," said Butchee, who retired as scoutmaster last year. "We thoroughly eradicated that and said no, not really. It's an organization for all boys."

Though Troop 96 is not exclusive to African-Americans, most of the scouts are African-American.

Butchee, who was a scout himself in the 1950s, said he helped re-start the troop in 1994 because he wanted his sons to learn the same skills and values he did from scouting.

His two sons, now grown, were part of the first wave of Eagle Scouts from Troop 96. In all, the troop has produced 10 Eagles.

The first three earned their Eagle Scout badges between 2003 and 2005, Butchee said.

That set the stage for the Class of 2008.

"We knew that we were making history and we knew it was something special from the start," said Butchee, who has known the seven Eagles since they first started in scouts.

They are: Nathan Knight of Apple Valley; Jacob Schwartz of Oakdale; Albert Williams Jr. of Minneapolis; Paris Michuta of Minneapolis; Paul Ndayizeye of St. Paul; Jonathan West of St. Paul, and Jonathan Williams of Minneapolis.

Scouts are eligible for the Eagle Scout badge until they turn 18. They must earn 21 merit badges, including 12 required ones.

The Eagles from Troop 96 relied on one another for motivation, Butchee said. "They were together for that whole run," he said. "They kind of pushed each other. It became like a challenge for each one."

Working for his merit badges gave Jacob Schwartz, 16, skills that he says he'll use the rest of his life. Through Scouts, he learned how to balance a checkbook and manage his money, and how to stay physically fit. And the classes he took to earn his citizenship badges taught him how the government works and his role in the community.

Sometimes, says Schwartz, it's hard for him to believe his scouting days are over.

The camping trips to Wisconsin, where he played football with his buddies and cooked barbecue chicken and vegetable "foil dinners" over an open flame, are among his fondest memories. "I just never had an experience being with a group of guys as close-knit for so many years," he said.

Though they go to different schools and live in different cities, the 2008 Eagles say they're as close as brothers. Four of them gathered recently at the church, greeting each other warmly and wasting no time in starting up a conversation. "The only reason I stayed through it was because of all these guys," Ndayizeye, 18, said.

Now that they've reached their goal, the friends are setting their sights on the next hurdle.

Said Williams: "What's stopping me from starting my own troop?"

Allie Shah • 651-298-1550.

about the writer

about the writer

Allie Shah

Deputy editor

Allie Shah is deputy local editor. She previously supervised coverage of K-12 and higher education issues in Minnesota. In her more than 20 year journalism career at the Minnesota Star Tribune, Shah has reported on topics ranging from education to immigration and health.

See Moreicon

More from No Section

See More

Peek inside homes for sale in the Twin Cities area.

card image