They were the Impeccable More-Tishans, a showy teenage rock and roll band that drew crowds of kids at ballrooms, bowling alleys, roller rinks and dance clubs. They recorded a hit song that was heard on radio stations in five states. They drove a hearse to their gigs. They played at least 500 concerts and dances in five years. Then, in 1968, they walked away from it all.
"I think we went as far as we possibly could," said bass guitar player Hugh Kraemer. "As I look back on my life I think that was a mistake. It was a huge popular time for guitars, the Beatles, rockabilly. It was a huge new time for rock and roll."
Now they're trifling with it again.
Today only Kraemer and the band's singer and rhythm guitarist, Chris Nelson, survive from the original More-Tishans. Lead guitar player Tom Cafferty has died, as has drummer Roy "Pinky" Herschleb. So have their replacements, Dick Schreier and Dan Munson.
They would be remembered for packed houses wherever they played and "(I've Got) Nowhere to Run," a regional radio hit. But like hundreds of other 1960s rock and roll garage bands, the More-Tishans drifted onto the littered road of music history.
The comeback of the fabled band is nothing short of remarkable, said Scott Schell, a Stillwater music historian.
"They set the bar for everybody else," said Schell, author of "Garage Sounds: Bringing Down the House," a book about Stillwater's many garage bands. "They had a manager and a gimmick and the good music. These guys, their summer job was playing music. They paid for their college educations. They ran their band like a business. It just totally baffles me how these four guys who had all this talent and were quite successful to some degree, that they could just walk away from it."
Now playing in halls and clubs in Washington County and once again drawing crowds, the new More-Tishans look different -- it's been four decades, folks -- but they play all the old songs and still advertise their dances with promotional signs on a hearse.