Waseca teen who plotted massacre could possibly go home next week

January 21, 2016 at 7:33PM
In this file photo, John LaDue was back in Waseca County in January 2015.
In this file photo, John LaDue was back in Waseca County in January 2015. (Star Tribune file/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

WASECA, MINN. – John LaDue, the teen arrested nearly two years ago for plot­ting a massacre at his school, could go home as soon as next week if auth­ori­ties can't find a spot for him at a state-operated treatment evaluation facility.

While his return home probably would last only until a facility bed opens, a judge said Wednesday that authorities can't incarcerate the 19-year-old beyond Jan. 28.

On that date, LaDue will have served his entire felony sentence for possessing an explosive device and can no longer be jailed, the judge explained during a hearing in Waseca County District Court.

As part of his plea last fall, La­Due had agreed to up to 10 years of probation, including an unspecified a;mount of treatment in a secure facility for his unusual combination of autism spectrum disorder and fixation on violence.

But as the legal proc­ess wore on and auth­ori­ties had dif­fi­cul­ty find­ing an ap­pro­pri­ate place to send him — their plans to place him at a Geor­gia fa­cil­i­ty fell through last month — they have been work­ing against the dead­line of his sen­tence end­ing.

If a bed in a state fa­cil­i­ty opens be­fore his sen­tence is over, he will go there. But if it doesn't, of­fi­cials are pre­par­ing to send La­Due home un­der pro­ba­tion un­til a bed be­comes avail­able — "what we hope is a short pe­riod of time," Judge Joseph Chase said.

Chase said he will is­sue a court ord­er this week to try to speed up place­ment in one of ap­prox­i­mate­ly a doz­en such beds in the state. He also said he an­tic­i­pated the ar­range­ment might up­set peo­ple in Waseca.

"I'm not very satis­fied with it my­self," he said. But, he add­ed, he is ask­ing the public to under­stand and "be­have in a man­ner that doesn't ex­ac­er­bate the sit­u­a­tion. … We'll get through this."

Af­ter his sen­tence is fin­ished, La­Due could le­gal­ly forgo pro­ba­tion, of­fi­cials said. But if he com­plies with the pro­ba­tion he agreed upon, a mis­de­mean­or will be put on his re­cord in­stead of a fel­o­ny.

Typ­i­cal­ly, in­mates who be­have well serve only two-thirds of a sen­tence and spend the rest out­side on super­vised re­lease. La­Due will have served his en­tire sen­tence but is agree­ing to pro­ba­tion.

"It's his wish at this time … to get help," Chase said.

If La­Due goes home, his par­ents have agreed to re­move any fire­arms from the house and deny him Web ac­cess. La­Due also could not leave the house ex­cept for authorized ap­point­ments.

Some time to talk

Police found La­Due in a Waseca stor­age lock­er in April 2014 af­ter a cit­i­zen saw him en­ter it sus­pi­cious­ly. He told auth­ori­ties of his plans to shoot his fam­i­ly, set a fire in the coun­try­side to dis­tract em­er­gen­cy of­fi­cials, and go to school with pres­sure-cook­er bombs and guns to kill as many peo­ple as he could.

Auth­ori­ties who searched the lock­er and the boy's bed­room had said they con­fis­cated chemi­cals, sev­er­al guns, am­mu­ni­tion and a few com­pleted ex­plo­sives. Officers con­clud­ed that he in­tend­ed to car­ry out the mas­sa­cre with­in a week or two.

The case has raised ques­tions about what to do with the teen, who had plot­ted but nev­er hurt any­one. His par­ents have said they be­lieve he nev­er would have car­ried out the plan.

La­Due's fa­ther said Wednes­day eve­ning that he and his wife were ex­cit­ed at the pros­pect of their son re­turn­ing home.

"We still have his gui­tars here and he'll have his cat here," David La­Due said. "I'll prob­a­bly of­fer, if he wants to, to look at the bas­ket of cards and let­ters we've re­ceived. … We'll have plen­ty of time to talk. We just want to have some peace and quiet. We'll just be glad that he's not be­ing held in jail, be­ing iso­lat­ed. We thank God very much for that."

Though he knows any stay would be tem­po­rary, David La­Due said he thinks it would be good for his son to get a break from the sys­tem be­fore he con­tinues on with thera­py.

"I know John has no in­ter­est in caus­ing any prob­lems. He wants this to be a mis­de­mean­or," David La­Due said.

While his par­ents were pleased, the news left some in =this southern Minnesota town of 9,300 a bit un­easy.

The pos­si­bil­i­ty was "very much a sur­prise," said form­er May­or Roy Srp. "My per­son­al feel­ing is we have to re­spect the ju­di­cial sys­tem, and if that is what the judge de­ter­mined, then that is what we have to live by.

"Now, it doesn't mean I like it."

Srp said he hopes the com­muni­ty re­acts with good­ness, and "that Waseca can re­main the peace­ful com­muni­ty that it is."

The Rev. Chris Meirose of First Con­gre­ga­tion­al Church called it a "no-win sit­u­a­tion." The teen, the judge and the com­muni­ty all want him to get treat­ment, he said, but "there's nowhere to get him the treat­ment … today."

Meirose said that per­haps a re­turn home will help La­Due: "He'll get time with his fam­i­ly, and may­be that will be good for him.."

Public safe­ty con­cerns

The case against La­Due ended in sharp con­trast to how it be­gan. Pros­ecu­tors in­i­tial­ly charged him as a ju­ve­nile with four counts of at­tempt­ed mur­der, two counts of at­tempt­ed first-de­gree dam­age to prop­er­ty and six counts of pos­ses­sion of a bomb by some­one un­der 18. But the at­tempt­ed-mur­der and at­tempt­ed-prop­er­ty-dam­age charges were dis­missed, with a state Appeals Court pan­el af­firm­ing that it could not "in­vite spec­u­la­tion as to wheth­er the acts would be car­ried out."

He e­ven­tu­al­ly pleaded guil­ty in a­dult court to just one fel­o­ny ex­plo­sive pos­ses­sion charge, with pros­ecu­tors agree­ing to drop the oth­er five.

Af­ter Wednes­day's hear­ing, Waseca County Attorney Bren­da Miller echoed the judge's sen­ti­ments, not­ing that a pro­ba­tion of­fi­cer will be check­ing in with John La­Due. She said she spe­cif­i­cal­ly asked that he re­main in­side the house be­cause she wants him to keep a low pro­file.

She cau­tioned peo­ple to call law en­force­ment if they have con­cerns.

"The last thing I want to do is to have to charge some­bod­y for going af­ter the LaDues," she said.

The plan to send him home if ne­ces­sary comes be­cause "we just don't have any time," Miller said.

"The oth­er op­tion is, we re­lease him and he goes wher­ev­er he wants," she add­ed. "I don't think the public wants that, eith­er.."

Staff writ­er Jen­na Ross con­tri­buted to this re­port.

Pam Louwagie • 612-673-7102

about the writer

about the writer

Pam Louwagie

Reporter

Pam Louwagie is a regional reporter for the Minnesota Star Tribune. She previously covered courts and legal affairs and was on the newspaper's investigative team. She now writes frequently about a variety of topics in northeast Minnesota and around the state and region.

See Moreicon