Advertisement

Walleye is Minnesota's most distinctive menu item

By our walleye we are known, say number-crunchers who tracked which foods are on the most menus in each state.

September 14, 2014 at 4:00PM
Walleyes that Mike Williams and friends caught the morning of Aug. 5, 2014 on Rainy Lake in Minn. were prepared in walleye sandwiches for lunch at the Kettle Falls Hotel at midday. (Sam Cook/Duluth News Tribune/MCT) ORG XMIT: 1156003
Walleye sandwiches are common fare for our trips Up North to whatever lake it is we call The Lake. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

In the spirit of Jeopardy: "What is 'walleye'?"

The clue: This food is Minnesota's most distinctive menu item.

The back story (and how the idea of game show antics isn't that far-fetched):

Food Genius, a Chicago group that analyzes menu data to predict food-industry trends, tracked how frequently certain foods or terms appear on menus in all 50 states.

"Walleye" is on 29 percent of Minnesota menus. Nationwide, only 1 percent of menus include our state fish.

(Which explains the "Huh?" uttered by visitors listening to the day's lunch specials.)

This number-crunching doesn't mean that walleye is Minnesota's most popular food, only that it's our most distinctive menu item.

Defining "distinctive," however, is in the hands of the number-cruncher.

Advertisement
Advertisement

This trend data appears at bit.ly/1nXNElx. But its methodology is coming under fire.

One example: Prawns are named Oregon's "distinctive" food, being on 28 percent of menus there compared with 9 percent nationwide, or about three times more often. Yet one commenter noted that Tillamook Cheddar (made in Oregon) is on 16 percent of the state's menus vs. 1 percent nationwide, for "a whopping 16 times [the] average."

Surely the weighted "uniqueness" of an ingredient compared to the national average should matter far more than the simple subtraction of percentages?

The official response:

" 'Distinctiveness' is already a somewhat dubious/difficult-to-measure concept."

So, well, yes, grains of salt all around!

Advertisement

Still, it's fun to toggle through the interactive graphic map for other distinctive foods and states: crawfish and Louisiana, green chile and New Mexico, grits and Georgia.

But ranch dressing and Iowa? Chocolate and South Dakota? Cinnamon and Alaska? Clickbait and the Internet?

All of which brings us back, game-show-wise, to: This food is Minnesota's second-most distinctive menu item, on 37 percent of local menus vs. 17 percent nationwide.

"What is 'bun'?"

Kim Ode • 612-673-7185

TOM WALLACE • twallace@startribune.com Assign#20011354A Slug: rn021810 Date: Feb 13, 2010 Loring Kitchen review 1359 Willow, Minneapolis, MN. A great-looking restaurant, on the corner of Willow overlooking the Loring Park. IN THIS PHOTO: The Walleye Slider plate.
Walleye has been dubbed a distinctive food in Minnesota, where it is even served in “slider” versions. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Advertisement
about the writer

about the writer

Kim Ode

Reporter

See Moreicon

More from No Section (Assign Gallery and Videos here)

See More
Advertisement
Advertisement

To leave a comment, .

Advertisement