WASHINGTON – The Senate on Tuesday turned away a bill that would have forced the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to repeal and rewrite new rules aimed at controlling pollution in streams, ditches and wetlands.
The "waters of the U.S." rules aim to clean up remote sources that feed the nation's rivers and lakes. They are opposed by many farmers and ranchers and widely supported by tourism interests.
A procedural vote to close debate on a bill that effectively gutted the rules failed to gain the needed 60-vote margin. The vote was 57-41 to stop debate.
Minnesota's senators, Amy Klobuchar and Al Franken, both Democrats, voted against ending debate. The move means new water rules stay in place for now.
Sen. Heidi Heitkamp, D-N.D., co-sponsored the defeated legislation, which gained 53 Republican and four Democratic votes.
"It's disappointing my bipartisan bill didn't move forward today," Heitkamp said in a statement after the vote. "But I'm going to keep educating senators about the need for our bill and explaining why the concerns of farmers and ranchers must be incorporated into any rule."
Franken said the proposed law was too drastic.
"In Minnesota, we all support clean lakes, rivers, and streams — including our farmers and ranchers, who are good stewards of the land and water," Franken said in an e-mail to the Star Tribune. "I have heard from farmers and some businesses who have concerns about the clean water rule. I'm listening to their concerns and raising them with federal officials. But I believe the legislation that came before the Senate today goes too far by repealing every aspect of this rule."