Sales of community banks -- and the premiums being paid -- are accelerating, reports Fredrikson & Byron attorney Karen Grandstrand, a former top bank regulator for the Minneapolis Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis.
Grandstrand should know. Her book of business has picked up markedly in the past year, a reflection of improved loan portfolios and community bank owners who are cashing out at prices well up from a couple of years ago.
For example, Grandstrand represented the recently closed sale of Western Bank of St. Paul, a well-capitalized, well-run community pillar owned by the Sands family since 1935. The buyer was Omaha-based American National Bank, about four times larger than 82-employee, four-branch Western. American will continue to run the Minnesota operation independently and under the Western name.
The price was not disclosed under a privacy provision of federal banking law that covers family-owned community banks.
However, Grandstrand said she's seeing well-run banks starting to sell for 150 percent of their book value. That's still a far cry from the two to three times book value that some banks brought during the go-go days of 2005-06.
But a year ago, savvy buyers were willing to pay only about book value for profitable, well-run institutions and they were getting troubled shops for a lot less in government-assisted deals.
"The merger-and-acquisition activity will continue because buyers and sellers are finally in agreement on pricing, regulators are starting to approve deals, buyers believe this may be the right time to buy from a pricing standpoint, and there are many very good bank franchises for sale," she said.
In addition to Western, Grandstrand has worked on a half-dozen other deals in recent months throughout Minnesota.