September was a rough month for Canada's top tech firms

Sector's stocks jumped nearly 60% in August, then gave much of it back.

Bloomberg News
October 2, 2019 at 7:42PM
IMAGE DISTRIBUTED FOR SHOPIFY INC. - Right Hon. Justin Trudeau, Prime Minister (right), and Shopify CEO, Tobias Lutke, have a fireside chat, Tuesday, May 8, 2018, in Toronto at Shopify's annual partner conference, Unite. (The Canadian Press Images PHOTO/Shopify Inc. via AP Images) ORG XMIT: CPALA402
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Shopify CEO Tobias Lutke chatted in 2018. Shopify hit a losing streak last month. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The best performing sector in Canada has lost its mojo.

After eight straight months in the green, tech stocks are now on pace for their first slump this year with about C$8.3 billion ($6 billion) in market value lost — making them the biggest losers in September.

The rotation to value from growth sent stocks like Shopify Inc. on its longest losing streak on record. There was also BlackBerry Ltd.'s 30% collapse last week after reporting a massive earnings miss and forecast cut. Shopify makes up a whopping 35% of the S&P/TSX Information Technology Index, while BlackBerry has about a 3% weighting.

"The pace of this recent run in technology stocks, driven in large part by the success of Shopify, was unsustainable, and likely driven in part by short covering," said Hans Albrecht, fund manager at Toronto-based Horizons ETFs Management Canada Inc. "When that dried up, the bottom fell out."

Was the epic 59% rally into August too good to be true? Sky-high valuations have slipped with the sell-off but are still well above the five-year average. Shopify, which has found profit elusive, carries forward a 12-month price-earnings ratio of about 466, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.

The slump may have also knocked Canadian pride down a peg or two. Shopify, along with Lightspeed POS Inc., whose shares have slumped about 38% since hitting a peak in August after pulling off one of the most successful initial public offerings in North America this year, have been held up as exhibit A and B that the country really can do tech.

"Is this the end of the run for tech? Absolutely not," Albrecht said. Unlike the U.S., Canada has a handful of tech stocks that make up a small part of the broader S&P/TSX Composite Index, pushing valuations up at an accelerated pace. "This year's run had valuations overextend and invariably investors realize that fundamentals need to catch up at least to some extent." The tech rally could take a pause for now and push ahead in 2020, he added.

Despite the flight to value this month, boosting heavyweights like financial and energy stocks, last week painted a different picture — stocks snapped their longest winning streak since April and have lost 1.2% amid political turmoil in the U.S. and evidence of slower growth in Europe.

about the writer

about the writer

Divya Balji

More from Business

See More
card image
Alex Kormann/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Revenue is down between 50% and 100% at immigrant-run businesses along Lake Street and on St. Paul’s East Side. Businesses say the impact is worse than COVID’s.

card image
card image