The headline on the letter asks "What matters most: hierarchy, victims, the faithful?" In another letter, the writer counts the hierarchy as seven male bishops. Victim claimants, according to a Star Tribune article of Aug. 30, number 400-plus. The "faithful" in the archdiocese total more than 800,000 (how "faithful" is defined in this case is not clear to me). The first letter writer claims the "church and its officials committed crimes, and there should be a price to pay." I agree, except my definition of "church" is more than just the mere hierarchy (officials) and the faithful. The "church" cannot commit a crime; the hierarchy, like the faithful, can commit crimes, but only as individuals. It's unlikely that the seven bishops (or their predecessors) and the 800,000 faithful colluded to abuse these "young lives."
Not being a member of any archdiocesan parish, I am not directly affected monetarily in this fight, but it seems to me that before liquidating all of these parish assets, do not those 800,000 individuals get their day in court? I say punish only the wrongdoers (when you find them guilty in court).
The letter writer states that "real change needs to follow." Well, in studying the last 50 years of church history, this whole mess seems to coincide when the personal attitudes of the majority of bishops "changed," after the council called Vatican II ended in 1965. Some of those changes led to relaxations that allowed some immoral men, a small few who became abusers, to be ordained to the priesthood, who then "preyed" mainly on young boys. Yes, maybe the "real change" the letter writer suggests would be to reinstitute the church that existed prior to the 1960s.
A Sept. 1 letter complained that many Twin Cities-area Catholic churches aren't open past normal business hours for people needing a spiritual break. As it just so happens, many are! In the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis alone, there are more than 43 Perpetual Adoration Chapels at local parishes (more than any other diocese in the U.S.). Most of these are open almost 24/7 for anyone, even "faithful strangers," who want to just get away and say hi to our Lord. A full list can be found on the archdiocesan website (www.archspm.org).