I have to take the Star Tribune Editorial Board (and by extension, Gov. Mark Dayton) to task for the June 12 editorial "Time to give licenses to all immigrants." Logically, any driver, citizen or not, will be inherently more dangerous to others if not properly trained before being permitted to drive on Minnesota roads, as the editorial argues. But allowing undocumented aliens to apply for, and receive, a Minnesota driver's license, regardless of the training involved, is wrong on many levels.
First, the Editorial Board uses the phrase "undocumented immigrants," granting more legitimacy than deserved to that group of people. Immigrants go through a legal process for entry into the U.S., without which they are illegal aliens. By choosing to allow illegal aliens to legally obtain a driver's license, the state will have, at a minimum, tacitly given approval for past illegal actions, namely crossing the border into the U.S. illegally. Would you wish to grant a permit to carry a gun to someone who has committed an armed robbery previously?
On another level, the governor is so concerned with granting licenses to illegal aliens, but we as a state have done little or nothing about distracted driving or about driving while under the influence of substances other than alcohol. These issues likely maim and kill many more people than do "untrained" illegal aliens. This is clearly more of an effort for Dayton to enact his policy desires than addressing a legitimate safety concern.
Governor, you, the Legislature and indeed the Editorial Board need to focus on the real safety issues we face. Perhaps one day, if and when the entirety of the immigration reform debate is settled, we can address the fairly minor issue of training unlicensed former illegal aliens to drive and granting them licenses. But that day is definitely not today.
Richard Rivett, Chaska
THE TRUMP PRESIDENCY
Praise from around the table
Monday's Trump administration Cabinet meeting provided an interesting lesson in psychology. The leader of the most powerful nation on Earth is so painfully insecure yet powerful enough to turn a group of successful men and women into lemmings and lap dogs ("Cabinet pays tribute to Trump," June 13). The only exception, not surprisingly, was Defense Secretary Jim Mattis, who refuses to be cowed and remains true to himself.
Ned Kantar, Minneapolis
HEALTH CARE
The idea of spreading the risk
While the U.S. Senate discusses the latest health care bill behind closed doors, I am at the clinic. I was diagnosed with Crohn's disease in 2005 and get an infusion every eight weeks. This medication has helped keep the condition under control, and I haven't had any problems in years.
The sticker price for each infusion is around $12,000. I didn't ask for it to cost that much, but that's what it costs. From a dollars-and-cents perspective, no insurance company would ever deal with me if they didn't have to. I've been lucky to have good coverage, but would rather not have to depend on luck.
I don't have all the answers about how to best pay for health care (though many other countries seem to have a handle on this), but I would note that both insurance and government are just tools to organize ourselves with our neighbors, supposedly for the common good. Healthy people pay insurance premiums, and wealthy people pay taxes, to help pay costs that the sick or poor can't afford on their own. Call it what you want, but when you take away the paperwork it's just about looking out for each other.