My favorite time of year — well, in addition to the playoffs, and opening night, and the trade deadline and, uh, the opening bell of free agency — is when the awards ballot hits my inbox. As I prepare to cast my votes next week for the players, to steal a phrase, who made the NHL great again, here's what I'm thinking:
Hart Trophy (voted by the Professional Hockey Writers' Association, most valuable player "to team")
Any other year I'd vote for Dallas Stars captain Jamie Benn because last year's Art Ross Trophy winner is the model of consistency, but what a year for Chicago's Patrick Kane. The first American to win a scoring title by a mile, Kane topped 40 goals and 100 points for the first time after basically having to hole himself up during the offseason because of a legal issue that eventually was dropped. His 26-game point streak made for a scintillating part of this season. Winner: Kane. Runners-up: Benn; Alex Ovechkin, Washington; Sidney Crosby, Pittsburgh; Roberto Luongo, Florida.
Norris Trophy (voted by PHWA, best defenseman)
The debate started weeks ago over Drew Doughty and Erik Karlsson. Karlsson has won two Norris Trophies, and his impact on the game for Ottawa is like no other, as Wild fans surely learned during two meetings. Karlsson topped 80 points, but as a former star defenseman asked me last week, "Should a guy win the Norris if he doesn't play the penalty kill or when they're up by a goal in the last minute?" Plus, the Senators didn't make the playoffs. Doughty logged the third-most ice time behind Karlsson and the Wild's Ryan Suter and had another tremendous year on a Kings blue line that isn't as good as past years. It's about time Doughty wins a Norris. Winner: Doughty. Runners-up: Karlsson; Brent Burns, San Jose; Kris Letang, Pittsburgh; Roman Josi, Nashville.
Calder Trophy (voted by PHWA, best rookie)
It's been an amazing rookie class, and in any other year, I'd probably vote for Edmonton's Connor McDavid (1.09 points per game). But even though it's not his fault, I can't vote for a guy who played only 45 games after seeing the full body of work from previously unheard of Artemi Panarin. How can you not pick a guy who probably wasn't on anyone's Calder prediction list before the season? To me, this young Chicago talent plays like a right-shot Kane. He's vying for top 10 in overall league scoring, not just being the NHL's top-scoring rookie by 20 points. Winner: Panarin. Runners-up: McDavid; Shayne Gostisbehere, Philadelphia; Jack Eichel, Buffalo; Dylan Larkin, Detroit.
Vezina Trophy (voted by the 30 GMs, best goaltender)