The closing of Nye's original piano bar a few years ago has left a gaping hole in the hearts of many a Twin Citian who loves a singalong from another era.
Trying to fill that hole is the new Barrel House, in the lower level of Birch's Lowertown (289 E. 5th St., St. Paul, 651-432-4677, birchslowertown.com). The 1970s-style cocktail lounge and cabaret opened last weekend.
If having a complicated entrance is the requirement for being a speakeasy, then that's what the Barrel House is. At least, that's what owner Burt Joseph (in partnership with Tim McKee and Shane Oporto of Market House Collaborative co-tenants Octo Fishbar) was going for. Go through the brewery, down the stairs and through the doors. "You walk in and have that wow factor," Joseph said.
But that's where the 1920s end and the 1970s begin. "I didn't want to do what other places had done with speakeasies," Joseph explained. "I wanted to try a time that was more fitting for myself and a style of music I enjoy."
Though he wouldn't give his age, Joseph said he was "riding my tricycle" in the 1970s. "I've got memories of the paneling in our lower level and some of the furniture my parents had back then."
The Barrel House is styled after a subterranean crooner's lounge from that era, complete with crushed velour swivel chairs and acrylic tables. "Where Elvis meets Liberace," Joseph described it. "With a little Studio 54."
For music, think "early Billy Joel." Singers Erin Schwab and Jay Fuchs, and Jenny and Donnie La Marca, currently headline around the piano, but on opening weekend, guests were doing a lot of the singing. And that's all right with Joseph. "If you ever went to Nye's and sang along, that's what I'm looking for," he said.
Guests can order off the Birch's menu till 10 p.m. Otherwise, the focus is on drinks, with more than 90 scotches, bourbons and ryes, more than 21 tequilas, and a Tattersall cocktail menu, plus a few throwbacks like the Harvey Wallbanger.