Ron Nelson bought his Market House condo in St. Paul's Lowertown district three years ago because he wanted to "have all the benefits of urban living."
And he didn't have to sacrifice his two cars, since the condo association had a gated lot across the street.
But now that lot is only a few months away from being taken by the city for construction of the Saints ballpark, leaving residents like Nelson to worry about how its loss will affect the market value of their condos and where else they might find convenient parking.
"It's a shock to … have it yanked out from underneath you," he said.
The Market House situation is the most pointed example of growing concerns in booming Lowertown about whether the area can absorb thousands of visitors drawn by the 7,000-seat ballpark, to open in 2015, without making it more difficult for those who live and work there.
St. Paul estimates there are more than 11,500 parking spaces within walking distance of the ballpark. That's about 4,000 more spaces than identified last week in an environmental work sheet analyzing the effect of the $54 million ballpark project on the surrounding area, but city officials said they based their figures on a bigger swath of downtown.
The environmental report also noted that the ballpark will displace about 320 on- and off-street spots used by public and contract parkers on or near the former Gillette/Diamond Products plant, which will be demolished this spring to make room for the ballpark.
That would still leave about 7,200 parking spaces within six blocks of the ballpark site, according to the report. It isn't clear how many of those spaces are for contract parkers. But downtown St. Paul has an estimated 7,000 residents, at least half of them living in Lowertown.
Competing for spaces
It's not that parking is lacking, Lowertown resident and business owner Jim Ivey said. The concern is that existing parking will become increasingly unable to accommodate the conflicting needs of residents and visitors.
"The problem is in terms of convenience, variety of needs, the demands of art students and disabled people, overnight parking, snow emergencies — and this all competes with event parking and everyday parking," Ivey said.
"We have a very large residential base compared to the rest of downtown, and we don't have a lot of large parking garages to put them in."
One such garage will be lost this year, when Sherman Associates converts the 300-stall contract parking garage in the Rayette Building, across from the Farmers Market, into an 88-unit apartment complex.
But project manager Chris Sherman said that only 50 to 60 spaces are being leased, leaving most of the garage's floors empty. Not only will the new apartment building include 64 parking stalls for tenants, he said, the company is working to find other parking for the contract parkers who will be displaced.
Paul Mandell, a planner who heads a working group on parking for the downtown Capitol River Council, said the city doesn't require developers using private money to include parking with downtown housing projects. That's to create density and also encourage transit use.
But downtown St. Paul badly needs a parking plan, he said. "There's a pressure valve already, even without the Saints. The days of cheap, unimproved parking are waning."
More bike lanes, shuttles
Ivey and Mandell believe that any solution must go beyond simply building more parking. Ivey said the city should encourage more two-wheel transit by designating more bike lanes and bike parking spaces..
Loading zones could be set aside at residential buildings to make it easier to carry groceries and move belongings. More downtown establishments could use shuttles to move fans from the bar to the ballpark. A public information campaign, similar to what Minneapolis did with Target Field, could suggest different ways to get to and from Lowertown.
"I don't know how this gets resolved without making the kinds of investments to make it an easy city to go without a car," Ivey said.
Back at Market House, Nelson said that St. Paul has offered residents a lump-sum payment for the loss of their parking lot. They would prefer to get a parking space instead, he said.