If you look back to the 2006 Twins, when Torii Hunter was the center fielder, Luis Castillo the second baseman, Jason Bartlett the shortstop and Matt Garza and Johan Santana were on the pitching staff, you realize how much the Twins lost when these players left the club.
They have had a very difficult time filling the holes left by trades, or players signing with other clubs as free agents.
Carlos Gomez, who came to the Twins in the Santana deal, certainly hasn't filled Hunter's shoes. He might have a future since he is a great outfielder, but he is hitting only .225. The other players who came here in the Santana deal are Kevin Mulvey, who is 2-2 with a 3.75 ERA for Class AAA Rochester, and his teammate, pitcher Phil Humber, is 1-1 with a 6.12 ERA. The other pitcher secured in that deal, Deolis Guerra, is 3-4 with a 5.05 ERA at Class A Fort Myers. Meanwhile, Santana is 6-1 with a 1.50 ERA for the Mets.
The Twins received two extra draft choices when Hunter left as a free agent for the Angels, using them to select two pitchers: Carlos Gutierrez, who is 2-1 with a 0.98 ERA for Fort Myers; and Shooter Hunt, who is 0-1 with a 10.70 ERA for Class A Beloit. Both are rated outstanding prospects. Meanwhile, Hunter is hitting .323 and has driven in 40 runs this season.
In the trade that sent Castillo to the Mets, the Twins received catcher Drew Butera and outfielder Dustin Martin, who both entered Wednesday hitting .221. Castillo is hitting .283 for the Mets and playing a strong second base.
Then you had the trade that sent Garza and Bartlett to Tampa Bay for outfielder Delmon Young, infielder Brendan Harris, outfielder Jason Pridie and pitcher Eduardo Morlan. Young is hitting .284 with 14 RBI and Harris is hitting .257, while Pridie is hitting .240 for Rochester. Bartlett, who was voted Tampa's MVP last year, is hitting .373, although he was placed on the disabled list this week. Garza, who was the MVP in the 2008 ALCS, is 4-3 with a 3.65 ERA.
Santana signed a contract for $137.5 million over six years with the possibility of making $151 million over seven years. Hunter signed a five-year deal with the Angels for $90 million. And Castillo signed a contract for four years for $25 million.
The point I'm trying to make is that, had the Twins decided to sign Hunter, and not have made the deals involving Castillo, Santana, Bartlett and Garza, they would have a lot more solid club with fewer holes in the lineup. They have Justin Morneau and Michael Cuddyer under long-term contracts.