Holder says voting rights threatened

The attorney general said overt and subtle forms of discrimination are widespread.

January 17, 2012 at 2:09AM
President Obama and daughter Malia participated in a community service project at a Washington, D.C., school in honor of Martin Luther King Jr.
President Obama and daughter Malia participated in a community service project at a Washington, D.C., school in honor of Martin Luther King Jr. (Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

COLUMBIA, S.C. - In his bluntest comments to date, Attorney General Eric Holder said Monday that voting rights, particularly for minorities, are under assault in some states.

Speaking at a Martin Luther King Jr. holiday event in Columbia, Holder said some states had sued to challenge provisions of the Voting Rights Act and had approved new laws that would make it difficult for some minorities to register and vote this year, five decades after King and other civil rights leaders fought for access to the ballot box.

"Each of these lawsuits claims that we've attained a new era of electoral equality, that America in 2012 has moved beyond the challenges of 1965," Holder told hundreds who gathered outside the South Carolina Capitol. "I wish that were the case. But the reality is that -- in jurisdictions across the country -- both overt and subtle forms of discrimination remain all too common."

He called protecting the right to vote not only a legal issue but also a moral imperative.

Holder's comments come nearly four weeks after the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division ruled that South Carolina's voter identification law was discriminatory because it would make voting harder for minorities -- who lack sufficient forms of government-approved identification more often than whites do.

Justice Department officials weighed in on the law under Section 5 of the 1965 Voting Rights Act, which requires approval of proposed voting-law changes in 16 mostly Southern states because they have histories of discrimination.

"We'll also continue to review other types of changes to our election systems and processes -- including to the procedures governing third-party voter registration organizations, to early voting procedures and to photo identification requirements -- to ensure that there is no discriminatory purpose or effect," Holder said.

South Carolina is one of 13 mostly Republican-controlled states that have approved new voting laws that include requiring government-approved photo ID to register or vote, shortening early voting periods and curtailing voter registration efforts by third-party groups such as the League of Women Voters and the NAACP.

Supporters of the new laws say they're needed to protect against voter fraud. Several studies and investigations -- including a five-year probe by President George W. Bush's Justice Department -- indicate that voter fraud in the United States is negligible, however.

Opponents view the new laws as a thinly veiled attempt to suppress the votes of minorities, the elderly and the young -- key voting blocs for the Democratic Party.

An October study by New York University's Brennan Center for Justice estimated that the new laws would adversely affect more than 5 million voters nationwide, mostly minorities.

about the writer

about the writer

WILLIAM DOUGLAS, McClatchy News Service