The old cookbooks don't lie: Flipping through their meat chapters reveals a flow chart of the highs and lows of venison popularity over the years.
Early American cookbooks, the ones published before 1900, are full of venison recipes, as well as recipes for duck, wild turkey, rabbit and squirrel. In my grandma's well-worn copy of the popular "American Woman's Cook Book," from 1938, venison warrants a handful of entries in the game chapter. Yet by the time we get to my mom's 1973 "Betty Crocker Cookbook," I can't find a single mention of venison. The meat chapter, at one time home to a menagerie of edible animals, focused mainly on the big three: beef, chicken and pork (with lamb a distant fourth).
Although the "Martha Stewart Living Cookbook" from 2000 does include a token recipe for farm-raised venison loin, most mainstream cookbooks have abandoned venison cookery. Culinary questions about game have been officially redirected to specialty outdoor stores. (My recent visit to Cabela's confirmed their foray into the ambitious camp kitchen. Next to an immense display of cauldrons, slicers and sausage stuffers, a bookcase held numerous venison cookbooks.)
The lack of professional guidance may be a hidden blessing. Most fans of venison possess strong independent streaks and actually prefer to wing it. Because eating venison is so wound up with hunting venison, perhaps cruising books for the perfect recipe and then following it to the letter obscures the point of it all.
Hunting is an improvisational act, based on lightning-quick responses to the natural environment. Good cooking works the same way. It is the art of responding to ingredients to create delicious food that satisfies a particular, personal and present hunger.
I think the best venison recipes are deeply personal and evoke the time and place in which they were first created. All of the hunters I talked to spoke only of their signature dishes -- stroganoff, a venison and apple wine stew, venison chili and venison cooked with wild rice -- as if they felt no further need to experiment. When it came to cooking what they had brought down, each felt that they had reached the peak of their own culinary powers.
The art of the hunt
I grew up and currently live in a town where venison shows up regularly on dinner tables. This is a community that observes the deer season opener as if it were the Christmas holiday. Come the first week of November, some businesses shutter their doors, local radio plays a catchy deer camp ditty ad infinitum, generally clean-shaven men grow scraggly beards and school absenteeism -- for kids and teachers alike -- goes widely unchallenged.