Carl Eide thought he'd spend his remaining years in the house he's lived in for the past four decades. Instead, at 82, he finds his home, his life and his finances in chaos.
Eide has been evicted from his 1890 home, one of the oldest buildings in St. Louis Park. The crumbling house on busy Minnetonka Boulevard perches awkwardly above a 5-foot-deep trench around its perimeter, the legacy of a failed renovation that caused more problems than it solved.
And after a two-year court battle, Eide's home is scheduled to be demolished at the end of January — on his 83rd birthday.
"The whole thing is just a rotten set of circumstances," Eide said.
With his muscular frame, leather jacket and gray ponytail, Eide looks every inch the biker he's been his whole life. He sold and repaired motorcycles for decades and has been active in racing and classic bike associations. The living room in his house is neatly lined with bookshelves holding a trove of motorcycle and auto shop manuals and racing publications.
But his main problems are outside the house. It all began a couple of years ago, when the front porch started to sag away from the building.
"That started everything, more or less," Eide said.
Never quite enough
The story of Eide's house, documented in two years' worth of court filings, tells of an earnest effort on both sides to deal with an ancient home that was admittedly falling into disrepair.
Time and again, city inspectors would order Eide to make fixes. Time and again, he would make them — but never quite to the point of correcting all the issues. Time and again, the city would give him another chance.
He hired a contractor to fix the sagging porch, but the contractor failed to get a permit and the city shut down the work. That led to increased scrutiny of the property and demands for additional repairs. The home's brick siding — not a structural element, but a veneer over the wood underneath — was cracked and needed to be reinforced.
Eide hired a mason to shore up the brickwork. That meant digging a trench to install support footings. When the trench was dug, some of the brickwork veneer broke away, revealing areas of rotted wood and deficiencies in the home's foundation. The work was shut down again, and Eide entered a long legal limbo.
City says it's been patient
The repairs and the lawyers have stretched Eide's finances to the limit. Even before his battle with the city, he had spent a considerable amount repairing the house, he said.
About seven years ago, he got a reverse mortgage. But the bank required some significant renovations before it would sign off on the deal. At that time, Eide said, he upgraded the plumbing and electrical, had the house painted and put on a new roof. Between the initial round of repairs and the more recent renovation, the balance he owes to the bank has ballooned from $66,000 to $177,000.
"I'm an old Norwegian, concerned about my money," he said.
There's a "For Sale" sign in front of the house, but at this point it can be sold only as a teardown. The property — more than two full city lots near one of St. Louis Park's busiest intersections — is listed at $215,000.
City officials say they've been more than patient with Eide.
"It's unfortunate when any house deteriorates to the point that we have to get involved," said Brian Hoffman, director of inspections for St. Louis Park. "But it's pretty hard not to notice the front porch falling off." Hoffman said Eide has had ample time to either sell or repair the house.
"He had about a year to do that," Hoffman said. "Through this period, in the legal process, the attorneys have talked and tried to come up with some solutions. He could have sold it or repaired it. When it gets to the point that it becomes a public hazard, something has to be done.
"There's nothing wrong with a 200-year-old house," Hoffman said. "It's just a matter of how it's built and how it's maintained."
'It's going to be rough'
Eide insists that, given more time, he could have completed all the necessary repairs to the house.
"Basically, I wasn't allowed to fix it," he said. "If that contractor had been allowed to go ahead, it would have been done." The masonry contractor, Jeffrey Cornell, agrees.
"That house would never fall in," Cornell said. "It's been there 100 years. There's no doubt in my mind that I could have repaired the foundation."
But at this point, Eide and his family seem resigned to the idea that their battle is over.
"I think we've come to the conclusion that the house is going to be torn down," said his son, David, who has helped his father with legal bills. Eide's only wish now is for more time to remove his personal effects, as well as some vehicles he has stored on the property. A deadline at the end of January, he said, is too soon to remove 40-plus years' worth of possessions.
Eide won't be destitute. He owns a rental property in Minneapolis and has been living there. But he was counting on the rental income from that house to supplement his Social Security payments.
"I imagine I'll have enough to live on, but it's going to be rough," he said. "Ideally, what I'd like to do is fix this house. But it doesn't look like that's going to happen."
John Reinan • 612-673-7402