Two of my recent blog posts have been about the need for combustion air ducts and common problems with combustion air ducts, but I never covered the topic of connecting a combustion air duct directly to the plenum on a furnace.  This actually used to be standard practice for a long time; the crude diagram below shows how this worked.

Combustion Air Connected to Return Plenum

When the combustion air duct is connected directly to the return plenum for a furnace, the blower fan on the furnace pulls outdoor air in to the return plenum.  To supply this air to the furnace room, a supply register is added at the ductwork in the same room, typically right above the furnace.  This is an undesirable setup, for a number of reasons.

Waste of Energy

During the winter, this setup pulls cold outdoor air in to the house, directly in to the return plenum for the furnace.  While a combustion air duct that terminates at the floor will allow cold air to come in to the house, it's not nearly as much air compared to the duct connected to the furnace return plenum.  When it's very cold outside outside, that's a ridiculous amount of cold air being pumped in to the house, but because it gets tempered by the furnace, nobody feels it.  This is a big waste of energy.

Combustion air connected to return (winter)

During the summer, the opposite happens.  This setup pulls warm, moist outdoor air in to the house just before the air conditioner's evaporator coil, as shown below.  Again, this is a waste of energy.

Combustion air connected to return (summer)

Pressurizes the House

When a combustion air duct is connected directly to the return plenum on a furnace, the house becomes pressurized when the furnace blower fan starts running.  How does this air leave the house?  Any way it can; plenty of these household air leaks were covered in this post about why houses need combustion air ducts.

The air leaks that really cause problems are the air leaks found in the attic.  Attic air leaks lead to frost in the attic as well as ice dams, and the effect is magnified when a combustion air duct is connected to a furnace return plenum.

Code Violation

As a home inspector I don't get hung up on code requirements, but as long as I'm blogging about this topic, it's worth mentioning that the Minnesota State Mechanical Code no longer allows the combustion air duct to be connected to the return plenum.  Section 708.1, #3 says:

[Combustion air ducts shall:] Terminate in an unobstructed space allowing free movement of combustion air to the appliances.

Frequently Disabled

While it's common for home inspectors to find combustion air ducts stuffed shut with clothing inside the house, it's actually even more common for the combustion air duct to be disabled when it's connected to the return plenum.

Remember, that register above the furnace is what supplies combustion air to the furnace room.  Because this register is located right above the furnace, it's also the most powerful register in the house, which makes the furnace room very warm during the winter.  When well-intentioned homeowners don't understand how their combustion air is connected, they assume that the register above the furnace is only there to supply heat to the room, so they block it off to get more heat to the areas that matter.  This prevents combustion air from getting to the appliances that need it.

Note the cardboard blocking this opening in the photo below, despite the stern warning from the HVAC contractor.

Blocked combustion air supply

What To Do

If the connection from the combustion air duct to the return plenum is visible inside the house, the fix for this situation is simple: have the combustion air duct disconnected from the furnace return plenum, and have the duct dropped down in to the room.  Also, have the old hole in the return plenum blocked off.

Combustion Air Disconnected from Return Plenum

Any HVAC contractor should be able to help make this simple change, which is something we've recommended to countless home inspection clients.

Author: Reuben Saltzman, Structure Tech Home Inspections


Older Post

New Safety Requirements for Bath Tub Faucets in Minnesota

Newer Post

How Bad Are Drum Traps?