Chris Farrell: Credit card company drops prompt payer

March 23, 2013 at 7:00PM

Q: I just received a note from my credit card company saying they won't renew my cards when they expire.

I will go talk to my local credit union, but I assume the reason is that I have been paying the bill off completely every month for several years now.

I use a credit card regularly for my everyday purchases, so it is not a dormant account. I always pay my bills on time, as is reflected in my great credit score (830-plus).

I would like to keep an active credit card, in case of an emergency. Would you suggest I start not paying it off at least once in a while, so they make some money in finance fees from me? Is there another option? Are the costs that I will pay in finance fees worth it to me to keep my good credit score?

BJ

A: What a pain. I don't know why your card got canceled. Cancellations were more common several years ago during the financial meltdown.

I guess you could fight it, but why reward the issuer with your business? You've done everything right with your credit card. You use it. You have kept a healthy gap between your balance and your credit limit. You paid the bill off on time and in full. I don't think you'll have difficulty getting another credit card with your financial history, especially if you go to a credit union or community bank.

By the way, I would look at your credit reports to make sure everything is on the up-and-up. By federal law, you can get a copy of your credit report from each of the three main credit bureaus for free once a year. There is only one authorized provider of the service, www.annual​creditreport.com.

Now to the heart of your question: Is it worth it to carry a balance and pay finance fees on your credit card?

Simply put, no. For a good credit score all you have to do is use the card on a frequent basis and keep the amount you borrow on the card low relative to your credit limit.

The credit-scoring companies — the main one is Fair Isaac — don't care if you carry a small balance or pay it off in full every month. So, from a personal-finance point of view it pays to get rid of the balance every month.

I know these are your habits already. I would maintain them, rather than pay unnecessary charges. You'll continue to have a good credit score.

By the way, no one really has a single credit score; it fluctuates, depending on when the credit snapshot is taken, when new information is added, and old information is deleted or declines in significance.

Fact is, you'll have a good credit score over time by paying off loans in a timely manner. Again, the key is maintaining good money habits.

Chris Farrell is economics editor for "Marketplace Money." His e-mail is cfarrell@mpr.org.

about the writer

about the writer

Chris Farrell

Columnist

See Moreicon

More from Business

See More
card image
Troy Thies Photography

Bryan Anderson with SALA Architects renovated his Bryn Mawr neighborhood house with his partner and earned a Home of the Month honor.

card image
card image