Q I have a 42-inch TV and want to upgrade my DVD player. I saw you recommended the Oppo 980H. Should I head in this direction or spend $399 and get the PS3 for Blu-ray? I watch movies and never play video games.

DAVID MCANALLEN, Pittsburgh

A My personal preference would be Blu-ray because I have a very large screen and a sound system fully compatible with the PS3. In your case we need to evaluate a few things to see if you want to get into Blu-ray right now.

With a screen larger than 50 inches the difference in picture quality between even the best DVD upscaling and Blu-ray is night and day, Blu-ray being far superior. At 42 inches the difference in picture quality isn't nearly as pronounced. Blu-ray audio is always much better, as long as you have a system capable of working with it. In the case of the PS3 this means a receiver compatible with multichannel PCM audio over HDMI.

Most consumers have older receivers with multichannel analog inputs. These work best with standalone Blu-ray players having multichannel audio outputs, a feature the PS3 lacks. Unfortunately, none of the Blu-ray standalones on the market are worth recommending, save a single model from Panasonic (the DMP-BD30) that costs $100 more than the PS3 but isn't as capable. Anyone wanting or needing a standalone Blu-ray player should definitely wait at least until this summer, when fully developed standalone players will be available.

The Oppo DV-980H is a great DVD player, but if you own a lot of DVDs or want the very best picture quality available from the DVD format, consider spending the $399 on the Oppo DV-983H. Oppo has built quite a reputation for customer service and DVD picture quality, and the DV-983H is state-of-the-art, providing noticeably better images than the DV-980H. (In a recent test the DV-983H duplicated the DVD upscaling scores of the $5,000 video processor I use in my own system.)

With the DV-983H you'd be extremely pleased with the image on your 42-inch TV, and there are a lot more movies available on DVD than Blu-ray. You will pay a lot less for the DVDs as Blu-ray movies are still quite expensive, often more than $30 each. And Netflix soon will be charging a premium for renting Blu-ray movies. If you want to buy Blu-ray movies I recommend using amazon.com, where you usually save more than $10 per movie.

To sum it up, if you have a sound system compatible with multichannel audio over HDMI, a screen larger than 50 inches, or simply want the best and don't mind paying for it, definitely go with the PS3 and Blu-ray.

If your sound system uses multichannel analog inputs, you have a really big DVD collection, you are price-sensitive or want the best possible image from DVDs, consider an Oppo player. With the Oppo, you can get the most from DVDs while you wait for competent Blu-ray standalones to arrive, and movie and player prices to come down a bit. Oppo is working on a Blu-ray player and when it hits the market (believed to be about a year away) it is likely to raise the performance bar while lowering the price.

You can see the PS3 at www. Playstation.com and Oppo DVD players at www.oppodigital.com.

Submit questions and read past columns at www.soundadviceblog.com.