EDINBURGH, Scotland — The election Thursday sent shock waves through Great Britain and Northern Ireland. The results will bring the return of a substantial Conservative majority, not seen since the days of Margaret Thatcher, with the party securing seats in traditional English and Welsh Labour strongholds. The United Kingdom now appears set to exit the European Union next month and will then enter an arguably more difficult stage of negotiations with Europe after that.
But the picture north of the English border was far different — and the result could launch a long standoff between the Scottish government and the new Conservative powers in London over whether Scotland remains part of the United Kingdom.
While the Scottish National Party, a center-left party seeking Scottish independence, did not replicate the 2015 landslide in which it won all but three Scottish seats in the House of Commons, it did extraordinarily well, taking all but one Labour seat, knocking the Liberal Democrat leader Jo Swinson out of her seat and halving the Conservative count.
The SNP ran on two key messages in this election: a pledge to stop Prime Minister Boris Johnson and Brexit, backing another referendum vote on the E.U., and a call to bolster their mandate for another referendum on Scottish independence. The SNP-controlled government in Scotland held a referendum in 2014, which lost with 45 percent of the vote.
But independence has been kept in the headlines by the SNP's performance in the 2015 election and the Brexit vote, which the party argues provides a mandate for another referendum on independence because Scotland voted 62 percent in favor of remaining part of Europe. The Brexit vote, in the SNP's view, serves as a "material change in circumstances," as outlined in their 2016 Scottish Parliament referendum, and Thursday's result is likely to amplify these calls. Whether the larger Conservative majority at Westminster will make more Scottish voters support independence remains to be seen.
Speaking as the results came in, SNP leader and Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon said that the result was a "clear endorsement Scotland should get to decide our future and not have it decided for us" and pledged to send a letter to Johnson requesting the power to hold a second independence referendum in 2020. The morning after the vote, she held firm: "So, to the prime minister, let me be clear: This is not simply a demand that I or the SNP are making. It is the right of the people of Scotland, and you, as the leader of a defeated party in Scotland, have no right to stand in the way."
The ability to make constitutional changes remains within the preserve of Westminster, unlike other powers devolved to the Scottish government. A legally binding referendum on independence is likely to require a Section 30 order transferring this power from the U.K. to Scotland, as it did in 2014, when the referendum was the result of a negotiation between then-Prime Minister David Cameron and Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond.
How might the Conservative government respond to Scottish calls for another referendum? The Conservative Party was heartened by an unexpected comeback in recent years in Scotland — it became the second-largest party in the Scottish Parliament in 2016, under the leadership of Ruth Davidson, and won 12 of Scotland's 59 seats in the House of Commons in the 2017 general election. It mobilized almost entirely on its opposition to any further referendum on independence and has been quite assertive in pushing that message. A vote for Scottish Conservatives was a vote against a second referendum, but it's unclear how they'll reconcile that message with their heavy defeat on Thursday.