In June 2005, a year after Dan Markingson committed suicide in a research study at the University of Minnesota, the state office of the Ombudsman for Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities issued a detailed set of recommendations addressing problems with the way university psychiatrists had handled Markingson's treatment.
University officials ignored the ombudsman's recommendations. For years afterward, they simply pretended that the ombudsman's report did not exist.
Eleven years later, Minnesota legislators want the ombudsman's office involved again. And this time, they want to give the ombudsman some real power.
In committee, Rep. Connie Bernardy, DFL-New Brighton, introduced an amendment to the higher education omnibus bill to have the ombudsman's office monitor participation of people in psychiatric research studies at the university. This was a recommendation made by a scathing Office of the Legislative Auditor report on the Markingson case in March 2015. The amendment has had bipartisan support, has passed the House floor and is now in conference committee.
An external monitor for psychiatric research would be a positive step forward. But the U's administration is opposing the bill.
I have been a nurse at the University of Minnesota Medical Center (formerly Fairview-University Medical Center) for 23 years. For the past 16 years, I have been a member of the university's Institutional Review Board, which is supposed to protect the rights and welfare of research subjects.
I was working at Fairview in 2003 when Markingson was pressured into enrolling in a study of antipsychotic medications. Markingson had been hospitalized under an involuntary hold. As part of the commitment process, he had been given a "stay" of commitment. This meant that he was required to follow the orders of his treating psychiatrist or face confinement in the state psychiatric hospital in Anoka.
I objected to Markingson's recruitment and participation in the drug study. I did not believe that a subject could give truly informed consent under these circumstances. But I was ignored. His mother strenuously objected. Her concerns were ignored as well.