Bad Seed

Michael Haneke's masterful parable of a German farm town plants the roots of the Third Reich.

Los Angeles Times
January 28, 2010 at 11:50PM
"The White Ribbon"
"The White Ribbon" (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

We don't go to Michael Haneke films for comfort, but to gaze through a glass darkly. That vision -- tense, provocative and unnerving -- is on full display in "The White Ribbon," a culmination of this difficult director's brilliant career.

Set in an ordinary German village on the eve of World War I, the film looks at the children who would grow into the generation that would bend to Hitler's sway. Shot in black and white, which serves as both a statement and a style, Germany's Oscar entry has rightfully been collecting critical acclaim since it took the top prize at the Cannes Film Festival last May.

Here the dramatic interplay of innocence, evil and human behavior so often on Haneke's radar has been joined by themes of guilt and responsibility. He's woven all this into a mysterious, often eerie parable that attempts to explain the seeds of Nazism. That the setting is a seemingly idyllic farming community is not accidental.

But accidents are very much at the heart of "The White Ribbon." As the narrator explains, there were a series of strange events years ago in his village that "could perhaps clarify some things that happened in this country." His grandfatherly, almost apologetic tone might lead you to expect that he will fill in all the missing pieces for us. Don't be fooled. This is a film that requires concentration -- a don't-blink, don't-breathe approach will serve the viewer well.

The world we're dropped into by cinematographer Christian Berger, whose work with Haneke includes two of the director's better known films, "Cache" and "The Piano Teacher," is both beautiful and harsh. The farmland, with its rolling fields of wheat, stands in lush contrast to the families in the region, hard folk tied to a rigid Protestant vision of morality, where pleasures are few, forgiveness is slow in coming and retribution rules the day.

"The White Ribbon" is told from the point of view of the village schoolteacher, with Christian Friedel playing him as a young man onscreen and Ernst Jacobi narrating as his latter-day, much wiser and reflective self. The story is framed by the family life of all those who make up the region.

It all begins when the village doctor (Rainer Bock) is thrown after his horse runs into a trip wire set on the road to his home. After school that day, the village children gather at the doctor's house. When someone spots them outside, innocent faces smile and explain that they're just there to see after their classmate, the doctor's teenage daughter.

But their politeness is eerie; the way they move through the village in groups suddenly seems sinister. Haneke is just starting to sow the seeds of mistrust, and like any good provocateur, he soon has us suspecting everyone in town of secret schemes and dark deeds.

Next, the farmer's wife is killed, the Baron's son is beaten, an infant catches a worrisome fever, and on it goes. There are no suspects and there are few clues, though the governing principle seems to be punishment.

While the accidents drive the action, they are also there to give context to the most significant question posed by "The White Ribbon": What is it about someone's childhood that creates the adults they become? Haneke, who wrote the screenplay with veteran Jean-Claude Carrière consulting, puts the responsibility on both parents and society as a whole, which leads you back to the question of who is minding the children.

In "White Ribbon," Haneke is, and it is to the children he always returns -- building scenes in such a way that you wonder: Are they responsible? Is it all or just a few? Planned or happenstance? And hovering over it all: Why?

Before we can condemn the children, the director begins opening the doors to their homes and the texture of their lives: the indifference in one household, the denial in another; neglect, or brutality, for others. Harshness and humiliation seem the guiding principles of parenting here.

That the story plays out in black and white makes things easier in a way -- the images have the beauty of old photos. History hovers over "White Ribbon" with the force of impending doom. These children will inherit this world of sin and sorrow, and the consequences will be catastrophic. Whatever responsibility we might feel for future generations after seeing a cautionary tale like this, well, that's just one of the questions Haneke leaves us to figure out.

about the writer

about the writer

Betsey Sharkey

More from Minnesota Star Tribune

See More
card image
J. SCOTT APPLEWHITE, ASSOCIATED PRESS/The Minnesota Star Tribune

The "winners" have all been Turkeys, no matter the honor's name.

In this photo taken Monday, March 6, 2017, in San Francisco, released confidential files by The University of California of a sexual misconduct case, like this one against UC Santa Cruz Latin Studies professor Hector Perla is shown. Perla was accused of raping a student during a wine-tasting outing in June 2015. Some of the files are so heavily redacted that on many pages no words are visible. Perla is one of 113 UC employees found to have violated the system's sexual misconduct policies in rece