We're supposed to believe that the 2019 Minnesota Twins have no chance to beat the 2019 New York Yankees because a bunch of currently retired players failed to beat previous Yankee teams?
That's a popular theme this week. It is flawed only in that it doesn't make sense.
Want to pick the Yankees to beat the Twins in the ALDS? You can rely on logic. The Yankees won more games, won a tougher division, have home-field advantage and are used to playing under intense pressure, and the Twins may start one game with a former Utica Unicorn on the mound.
Want to pick the Twins to lose because of a history that has nothing to do with their current roster? That's dubious.
Seven Twins expected to be on the Twins' ALDS roster played in the team's 8-4 loss in a one-game playoff at Yankee Stadium in 2017.
The three key position players who played in that game and are expected to be in the starting lineup Friday — Jorge Polanco, Eddie Rosario and Max Kepler — combined to go 3-for-10 with three walks.
The Twins didn't lose that game because they were overmatched, intimidated or paranoid. They lost because their veteran pitcher, Ervin Santana, gave up three runs in the first inning to erase the Twins' 3-0 lead.
The history that should inform this series occurred more recently, when the Yankees took two of three at Target Field in July.