All school and no work may be the new normal for teens

Chicago Tribune
August 1, 2019 at 6:44PM
Elayna Whiteman, 15, works as an attendant at Glencoe Beach on July 18, 2019, in Glencoe, Ill. Whiteman, a sophomore at New Trier High School, says having a job during the school year is "impossible," given academic demands.
Elayna Whiteman, 15, works as an attendant at Glencoe Beach on July 18, 2019, in Glencoe, Ill. Whiteman, a sophomore at New Trier High School, says having a job during the school year is "impossible," given academic demands. (Cathy Roberts — TNS/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The summer job, long an entry-level rite of passage into the working world for teenagers, is becoming obsolete.

Under pressure to bolster their college applications, more students are shunning the character-building, low-paying first job for extracurricular activities and year-round academics. Out are summers spent perched on a lifeguard chair slathered in zinc oxide, schlepping clubs on fairways or stacking boxes in a warehouse. In are science classes, tutoring sessions or other resumeworthy pursuits.

Take Magali Ortiz, 18, a graduate of Northside College Prep, who spent every summer vacation away from the elite, selective-enrollment Chicago public high school honing her powers of persuasion at a debate camp in Michigan.

"At my school there is sort of a culture of doing more academic things, as opposed to traditional jobs, during the summer," said Ortiz, who is headed to Tufts University.

All school and no work may be the new normal for teenagers. A study released this month by the Brookings Institution found that only 1 in 3 teenagers age 16 to 19 are working or looking for a job, down sharply from 2000, when more than half of teenagers were in the labor force.

Reduced demand for low-wage work because of automation and globalization, minimum-wage increases and competition from older workers and immigrants all play into the trend, Brookings found. But the most dramatic shift for teenagers is the replacement of summer jobs with summer school.

"We used to think summer — everybody is out of school," said Jay Shambaugh, a senior fellow in economic studies at Brookings who headed the research project. "A lot more high school students are actually in school in the summer than they used to be."

Last year, nearly a third of teenagers were enrolled in summer school and not seeking work, according to the study. In 2000, just 1 in 7 teenagers were exclusively summer school students.

To be sure, not every teenager has the resources to forgo a part-time job as a way to either help with household expenses or save money for higher education. For example, the One Summer Chicago teen jobs program has about 32,000 participating this summer, the city said.

But families of limited means also are prioritizing school over work, and the drop accounts for more than a third of the decline in the overall labor force participation rate since 2000, Shambaugh said.

Channick writes for the Chicago Tribune.

about the writer

about the writer

Robert Channick

More from Business

See More
Ten skids of loose peanut butter crackers wait to go to the land fill Saturday Feb. 7, 2009 as Gleaners Food Bank destroys products containing peanut butter as part of the nation wide recall of foods containing Salmonella tainted products from Peanut Corp. of America . (AP Photo/The Indianapolis Star,Michelle Pemberton)
The Minnesota Star Tribune

Gold Star Distribution, which supplies several Halal markets in the Twin Cities, is voluntarily recalling a list of food and merchandise products stretching 44 pages and including products from candy to medicine.

card image
card image