Name, Team 1st 2nd 3rd Points Bob Melvin, Athletics 16 12 116 Buck Showalter, Orioles 12 16 108 Robin Ventura, White Sox 12 12 Joe Maddon, Rays 7 7 Joe Girardi, Yankees 5 5 Jim Leyland, Tigers 2 2 Ron Washington, Rangers 2 2 Below is a breakdown of the 28 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each team in the American League. Note that in some cases (*), when a city does not have enough eligible voters, a writer from another city will represent that chapter. Name Affiliation Chapter 1st 2nd 3rd Peter Abraham Boston Globe BOS Showalter Melvin Ventura Anthony Andro Foxsportswest.com TEX Melvin Showalter Washington Mel Antonen SI.com BAL Melvin Showalter Girardi Chris Assenheimer Elyria (OH) Chronicle Telegram CLE Melvin Showalter Ventura Jeff Blair Toronto Globe and Mail TOR Showalter Melvin Girardi Erik Boland Newsday NY Melvin Showalter Maddon Asuka Brown Jiji Press SEA Melvin Showalter Maddon Pete Caldera Bergen (NJ) Record NY Showalter Melvin Girardi Jack Curry Honorary SEA* Showalter Melvin Ventura Bob Dutton Kansas City Star KC Melvin Showalter Ventura Jim Henneman Honorary BAL Showalter Melvin Ventura Chris Iott MLive Media Group DET Melvin Showalter Girardi Matt Kawahara Sacramento Bee OAK Melvin Showalter Girardi Tim Kawakami San Jose Mercury News OAK Melvin Showalter Maddon Gil LeBreton Fort Worth Star Telegram TEX Showalter Melvin Ventura Bruce Levine ESPN Chicago.com CHI Showalter Melvin Ventura Jeff Miller Orange County Register LA Melvin Showalter Maddon Roger Mooney Tampa Tribune TB Melvin Showalter Ventura Matthew Mowery Oakland (MI) Press DET Melvin Showalter Ventura Sheldon Ocker Akron Beacon Journal CLE Showalter Melvin Ventura Gregg Patton Riverside Press Enterprise LA Melvin Showalter Leyland Nicole Poell Kansas City Star KC Melvin Showalter Washington Tom Powers St. Paul Pioneer Press MIN Showalter Melvin Ventura Patrick Reusse Minneapolis Star Tribune MIN Melvin Showalter Maddon Mike Rutsey Toronto Sun TOR Showalter Melvin Maddon Naoko Sato Nikkan Sports News CHI Melvin Showalter Leyland Michael Silverman Boston Herald BOS Showalter Melvin Ventura Marc Topkin Tampa Bay Times TB Showalter Melvin Maddon