Aggressive search launched for Lake Elmo woman missing for 30 years

New cold-case unit looks into the night that Susan Swedell, 19, went missing.

January 22, 2018 at 4:00PM
Susan Swedell was last seen in January 1988 at a gas station about a mile from her home in Lake Elmo, Minn.
Susan Swedell was last seen in January 1988 at a gas station about a mile from her home in Lake Elmo, Minn. (Dennis McGrath/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The sister of a Lake Elmo teenager who went missing 30 years ago said Friday that her family had endured "crushing pain" not knowing her whereabouts for all those years.

"Grandparents, aunts and uncles, all passed away with only one wish — to know what happened to Sue," said Christine Swedell, the younger sister of Susan Swedell, who disappeared on Jan. 19, 1988.

Washington County Sheriff Dan Starry held a news conference Friday to announce that solving the mystery is the first task for his new cold case unit. "Today is about Susan," he said. "Today is about hope. We're determined to find a resolution for the family."

Joining Starry at the news conference, in addition to Christine Swedell, were Chief Deputy Brian Mueller, Investigations Commander Andrew Ellickson, County Attorney Pete Orput, County Commissioner Gary Kriesel, Superintendent Drew Evans of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension and three detectives working on the case.

"We're never going to let go of this until we can hold someone accountable to answer the questions," Orput said.

To draw more attention to the Swedell case, a walk will be held at 10 a.m. Saturday at Maplewood Mall, starting near the entrance to Kohl's, Starry said.

The night she disappeared, Susan Swedell, then 19, finished work at Kmart in Oak Park Heights and began driving home in the middle of a snowstorm. She had changed out of her work uniform and left work with no coat.

A few miles down Hwy. 5, she pulled into a gas station because her car was overheating. She asked an attendant where she could park her car, then the attendant watched her climb into a car driven by a tall, unshaven man. The car headed west toward downtown Lake Elmo. It was the last time anyone reported seeing her.

Christine Swedell, who was 16 when Susan disappeared, said the sisters were finding happiness again after their parents' difficult divorce.

"Why would everything have to be tragically pulled apart by pure evil on the night of Jan. 19, 1988?" Christine Swedell said. "Every single day feels like a living hell without her. I can still feel the touch of her hand, hear her soft-spoken voice, hear her laugh, and all the while someone out there knows what happened to my dear Sue. It's unbearable and sickening."

Starry said the unit will review the entire Swedell case, with detectives re-interviewing witnesses and looking to uncover new information. They have completed about 25 interviews, he said.

Investigators are approaching Swedell's disappearance as both a missing-person case and one that could involve foul play, he said, because "there's just not a lot of information out there about what happened that night."

A statewide billboard campaign has produced as many as 20 new tips, Starry said.

Evans said about 35,000 Minnesotans are reported missing each year, most of them juvenile runaways and vulnerable lost people who are located after a short time.

Starry said that anyone with information about Swedell's disappearance should call the Washington County Sheriff's Office tip line at 651-430-7850. A $25,000 reward has been offered for information leading to her recovery.

"We want to make sure we leave no stone unturned," Starry said.

Kevin Giles • 651-925-5037

Susan Swedell was last seen in January 1988 at a gas station about a mile from her home in Lake Elmo, Minn. .
Susan Swedell was last seen in January 1988 about a mile from her home. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Washington County Sheriff Dan Starry speaks at a news conference Friday to announce the formation of a cold case unit to investigate the disappearance of Susan Swedell. On his right, near a photo of her sister, is Christine Swedell.
Washington County Sheriff Dan Starry said Friday his new cold case unit would investigate Swedell’s disappearance. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Kevin Giles, Star Tribune