The first time I dined at Fig + Farro, I wondered if I was being punked.
It was last spring, a few months after the Calhoun Square vegetarian restaurant's debut, when the kitchen's leadership was a collective effort. Turns out that the whole too-many-cooks-spoiling-the-soup is an adage for a reason, because much of what was landing on the table was an unfathomable and unpalatable mystery.
This was despite the fact that plant-based cooking is firmly anchored at the forefront edge of contemporary American cuisine.
Owner and first-time restaurateur Michelle Courtright regrouped, did her restaurant a favor and hired a chef. Under Patrick Scott Moore, Fig + Farro 2.0 was a definite improvement, but his all-over-the-map menu was overpowered by quirky, overwrought dishes. Another disconnect: When I visited early last fall, local farmers markets were alive with an impressive array of vegetables, fruits, leafy greens, grains, herbs and other seasonal glories. Yet this bounty didn't seem terribly familiar territory at Fig + Farro. Shouldn't a plant-based restaurant celebrate, well, plants?
Courtright's motives are certainly admirable. She's casting a wide net beyond the small percentage of Americans who identify as vegetarian and vegan (5 and 3 percent, respectively, according to an August 2018 Gallup Poll), hoping to convince the Meatless Monday crowd on the merits of a plant-based diet, particularly when it comes to fostering a healthier planet and addressing climate change.
True to the Midwest, her advocacy — which extends to a monthly guest lecture series, classes and other events — isn't preachy or in-your-face. It's sensible, smart and engaging. If only those early menus had been a more convincing spokesperson.
Fortunately, Courtright embodies the virtues of persistence and stamina because, sometime late last fall, a switch seemingly flipped. She replaced Moore with Charlie Baez (he's since departed) and retained sous chef Andrew Vuong (he's still present, and doing a bang-up job running the show) and narrowed the kitchen's focus from vegetarian to vegan. With this newfound framework, Fig + Farro appears to have finally settled into its comfort zone and found its audience. Hurrah.
The cooking is now much more colorful, fresh and appealing. Yellow peas give crisp falafel a fluffy lightness, and instead of tahini, a garlicky tzatziki packs a welcome wallop. Cauliflower, very nearly a requisite on menus right now, is transformed into a tempting snack though delicate frying and Middle Eastern seasoning. I loved the eggplant dip, shimmering with garlic and oregano and made for scooping up with a firm flatbread.