Advertisement

A better route for Southwest commuter rail

August 15, 2013 at 12:32AM
<h3>Public Transit</h3><br />
<p><b>Importance:</b> Minneapolis needs to expand public transit to foster and accommodate population growth.</p>
<p><b>What:</b> The Metro Blue Line opened as the Hiawatha Line in 2004.</p>
<p><b>Context:</b> Passengers can travel on light rail from downtown Minneapolis to the Mall of America and several places in-between.</p>
<p><b>Other options:</b> Metro Transit also operates the Northstar Commuter Rail, which stretches 40 miles from Big Lake, Minn., to downtown
Metro Blue Line (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Two blocks! Resolution of the conflict on the Kenilworth Trail between freight rail lines, light rail and the bike path is only about two blocks.

I often bike the Midtown Greenway/Kenilworth trails. North of Cedar Lake Avenue (27th Street) and south of the Greenway intersection (29th Street), there is ample space to accommodate all three users, so the controversy is only about the two blocks between.

I find it preposterous that anyone would consider spending $330 million to build a tunnel to accommodate these conflicting interests for only two blocks when there are several less expensive alternatives. For example:

1)  All affected homes could be bought and removed for a fraction of that cost.

2)  Freight-rail and light-rail trains could use the same track — or overlap the two tracks — for two blocks.

3) The light-rail train could stop at Cedar Lake Avenue, with riders walking two blocks to catch the train at the Green­way. You can build a covered walkway for far less than $330 million.

4) The bike trail could be replaced with a pedestrian walkway so that bikers could walk their bikes for two blocks, then resume their ride. (There are actually several biking alternatives around this bottleneck area).

Adam Platt was correct in his commentary ("The wiggle room is in the bike trail," Aug. 11): Someone has to give a little to make this happen.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Don't change the freight lines. Freight traffic should continue on the same lines, but there are other westbound tracks if scheduling presents a conflict.

Mass transit in the form of light rail is here to stay, and we should all embrace it so that the next phase can be built. It will provide good transit alternatives and remove cars from our streets and highways.

All change has benefits as well as costs. Focus on the benefits. But first, eliminate the $330 million idea and focus on a better solution for these two blocks.

* * *

Bernie H. Beaver lives in Edina.
about the writer

about the writer

BERNIE H. BEAVER

More from Commentaries

See More
Minnesota DFL State Senator Omar Fateh calls friends and family members to tell them he intends to run for mayor of Minneapolis at Hosmer Library in Minneapolis, Minn. on Tuesday, Nov. 26, 2024

When young Muslim candidates are vilified simply for running, it sends a chilling message to young people from immigrant families who might otherwise step into public service.

President Donald Trump speaks to reporters at Joint Base Andrews in Maryland on Sunday, July 13, 2025, after attending the FIFA Club World Cup final in New Jersey. The fallout of the Epstein case is testing the power the president holds over his most loyal followers, many of whom have broken into open revolt against him. (Haiyun Jiang/The New York Times)
Advertisement
Advertisement

To leave a comment, .

Advertisement