The Carson Wentz question: Great money vs. great place to play quarterback

The North Dakota State star is being touted by experts as the second overall pick in the NFL draft. But some of his fans don't want him going to Cleveland.

March 23, 2016 at 5:22PM
North Dakota State quarterback Carson Wentz.
North Dakota State quarterback Carson Wentz. (TIM SHARP — ASSOCIATED PRESS - AP/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

It's Pro Day at North Dakota State on Thursday, which means that Bison quarterback Carson Wentz will be putting on a show for NFL scouts and the media. It's a big enough deal that the NFL Network is planning live coverage from Fargo starting at 9 a.m.

Some experts have Wentz being the second player taken overall, which would send him to Cleveland and the vacancy opened up by the spectacular failure of Johnny Manziel.

But there are those who love the Bison who want Wentz to go someplace else -- anyplace else -- ostensibly for his own good. Fargo talk-show host and newspaper columnist Mike McFeely explained on his blog why going anywhere but Cleveland is better in theory than reality.

Fans, McFeely wrote, want Wentz "to go to a solid franchise that has a chance to win, not a franchise that drafted Johnny Manziel and has made one playoff appearance since the mid-1990s. That's the North Dakota Way: Hoping for the best for somebody else (who won a lot of games and two national championships at your favorite college)."

But it's about the money, Or, as McFeely said: "The more Wentz drops in the draft, the more money it costs him."

He used the 2015 draft as an example, pointing out that Marcus Mariota, the No. 2 overall pick, signed for four years and $24.2 million in guaranteed money, including a $15.9 million bonus.

He cited two other examples: The No. 7 overall pick, Kevin White, went to the Bears and got $16.56 million, including a $10.3 million bonus. At No. 15, Wisconsin's Melvin Gordon got $10.67 million with a $6 million bonus from San Diego.

ADVERTISEMENT

McFeely writes: "While all Bison fans hope Wentz has a 15-year career and makes tens or hundreds of millions of dollars, the fact is the NFL is a brutal sport in which a career (and the money train) can end at any time. You want to make as much money as quickly as you can. It's not greed. It's just a fact. Going second to the Browns would mean the most money in Wentz's pocket right now."

So, he concluded: "If you want what's best for Carson, at least in the bank account, you want him to get picked second by the Browns."

You can read McFeely's complete post here. There's more good stuff there.

about the writer

about the writer

Howard Sinker

Digital Sports Editor

Howard Sinker is digital sports editor at startribune.com and curates the website's Sports Upload blog. He is also a senior instructor in Media and Cultural Studies at Macalester College in St. Paul.

See Moreicon

More from Gophers

See More
card image
Paul Vernon/The Associated Press

The Gophers had two shots to win it in the final seconds of regulation, but both fell short. They face unbeaten Nebraska next.

card image
card image