Suspect in Minnesota double murder shot at deputy before capture, Iowa sheriff says

Randy Zimmerman is charged with killing his ex-girlfriend and a small-town firefighter.

November 3, 2025 at 8:22PM
Tabitha Trescott was one of two people killed in the Sunday shooting. (With permission from GoFundMe)

The suspect in a double murder in a southern Minnesota home was captured in Iowa after trying to elude deputies at more than 100 miles per hour and shooting at one of them, officials said Monday.

Justin Paul Reinarts, 50, and Tabitha Leigh Trescott, 32, were killed early Sunday in their home in Hanska, about 30 miles west of Mankato, Fire Chief Mikale Gustafson told the Minnesota Star Tribune.

Randy Thomas Zimmerman, 45, of Courtland, Minn., was arrested in southeastern Iowa at about 4 a.m. Sunday, the Brown County Sheriff’s Office said.

Zimmerman was charged the same day in District Court with second-degree murder and remains held in the Louisa County jail in lieu of $5 million bail pending his return to Minnesota.

While Zimmerman’s apprehension in Iowa was made within 12 hours of the shooting, it came only after he put up stiff resistance, according to a sheriff in that part of the state.

Louisa County Sheriff Brandon Marquardt said his agency was alerted that Zimmerman was in the vicinity. The sheriff said license plate recognition technology detected the suspect’s car close by, but he “would take off at a high rate of speed before any stop was initiated.”

A subsequent law enforcement pursuit topped 100 miles per hour, the sheriff said, and that’s when Zimmerman fired once at one of the deputies but missed.

The second of two “PIT” maneuvers, a tactic law enforcement uses with its squads to disable vehicles, brought Zimmerman’s car to a halt, Marquardt said. Zimmerman fled on foot but was soon “taken into custody by force,” the sheriff said. A shotgun was recovered nearby.

Gustafson, who also serves on the City Council in the town of barely 400, said Reinarts was a lifelong Brown County resident who had been a friend of his for close to 30 years and was a firefighter for the past 17 years. Reinarts also worked floor security at Jackpot Junction Casino in Redwood Falls, Gustafson said.

“I’ve never seen him happier” than during his time with Trescott, Gustafson said.

According to the criminal complaint:

A boy called 911 and said he was awakened to someone yelling a vulgarity directed at a woman, followed by “ ‘I gave you a chance,’ ” the complaint read.

The boy said he saw Zimmerman and identified him as the person who broke into the family’s home and shot his mother. He said Zimmerman pointed a long gun at him and was ordered to go back into his bedroom.

The boy received a phone call from his brother reporting that Zimmerman texted shortly after the shooting to say he killed Reinarts and Trescott.

Court records in Minnesota show Zimmerman has five convictions for assault, three for drunken driving and two for burglary.

Anyone with information about the shooting is encouraged to call the Sheriff’s Office at 507-233-6720.

about the writers

about the writers

Paul Walsh

Reporter

Paul Walsh is a general assignment reporter at the Minnesota Star Tribune. He wants your news tips, especially in and near Minnesota.

See Moreicon

Eleanor Hildebrandt

Reporter

Eleanor Hildebrandt is a reporter for the Minnesota Star Tribune.

See Moreicon