THE MARC PEASE EXPERIENCE
★ out of four stars
Rating: PG-13 for brief sexual material.
Usually a movie starring Ben Stiller and "Twilight's" Anna Kendrick would be a big deal. So why is Paramount dumping "The Marc Pease Experience" with a theatrical release in just 10 markets nationwide? Easy decision. The film is an all-you-can-eat buffet of mediocrity. A spiraling vortex of boredom. A deflated Whoopee cushion.
The problem starts with the premise. The central character is an optimistic loser, but mostly a loser. Marc (Jason Schwartzman) is eight years out of New Ashby High, yet still dreaming of bygone days when he starred in the school's musicals. He's hounding his former music teacher, Mr. Gribble (Stiller), for guidance and hanging on Gribble's long-ago offer to help his a cappella group produce a demo CD. No matter that four of the original eight singers have moved on with their lives, a choice Marc has never considered.
Schwartzman plays his role as a charmless poster child for arrested development, and his idolatry/rivalry relationship with Stiller is smudgy and hard to read. Between Marc, a pest with some musical talent but unrealistic dreams, and Gribble, a lech who nevertheless is a truly caring and inspirational teacher, there's no real rooting interest here. The vague, icky emotional triangle among the men and high school senior Kendrick brings echoes of "Lolita" into the featherweight comedy, which is more emotional heft than it can support.
The climax is the most brazen cliché in the history of musical theater, presented here as a freshly minted inspiration. The action unfolds around the staging of a high school play, and, all things considered, I'd rather have seen one of those.
COLIN COVERT
POST GRAD
★ 1/2 out of four stars