Review: 'Academy Street,' by Mary Costello

FICTION: A concise, complex and resonant portrait reveals 70 years in the life of an Irishwoman who builds a life in New York.

For the Minnesota Star Tribune
April 25, 2015 at 4:14PM
"Academy Street," by Mary Costello
"Academy Street," by Mary Costello (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Mary Costello's "Academy Street" is a long-view novel in a succinct package. The story covers 70 years in roughly twice as many pages.

Antsy readers, take note: This is a book that can be finished in a couple of sittings. Remarkably, though, the narrative almost never feels rushed, its youth-to-dotage portrait of an Irishwoman who builds a life in New York as complex as an epic tale.

As the novel opens, it's the mid-1940s, and Tess Lohan, the book's central character, is 7. Her family's small farm west of Dublin is abuzz with activity. In one sharply etched scene, a blackbird zips through an open window and peels away a shred of wallpaper, darting off as quickly as it appeared. A hired hand tends a small orchard, and a "poultry instructress" drops by.

But the seemingly idyllic landscape has been touched by tragedy: Tess' mother is dead, probably from tuberculosis, and she rests in a coffin in the family home. Unfamiliar with loss, Tess fixates on the bewildering notion that the body is about to buried in a new dress. When she returns to school, her classmates are full of questions: "Did ye touch her — was she as cold as marble?" For a time, Tess is so shaken that she loses the ability to speak.

Her teens will bring a different set of challenges, as Tess juggles complicated sibling relationships, battles a protracted illness and learns to cope with her emotionally withdrawn father.

She's in her 20s when she moves to New York City, where she takes a job as a nurse and dates a man whom she'd like to marry. It turns out to be a brief fling, but one that results in a son, leaving Tess to raise the boy on her own. In these chapters, Costello ably captures Tess' wonder at American customs — "They stopped at a turnpike and paid a toll, just to use the road" — and the challenges associated with being a single mother in the 1960s. Tess buys herself a wedding ring to avoid shame.

Her life doesn't get easier in the book's second half. Although she forms a friendship that will be her most important bond, Tess, in her 60s, must also cope with a sudden loss.

This arrives in a chapter in which Costello advances the narrative by fusing it to an enormous real-life news story. Her decision to do so feels a little manipulative, but her handling of Tess' grief is nimble and assured.

Costello is an Irish writer whose debut, a 2012 story collection called "The China Factory," was in contention for several awards. In this book, she occasionally demonstrates a dilettante's understanding of American life; once or twice, she discusses racial matters, and these passages are notable for their lack of insight. But on the whole, she's written a resonant first novel about a character who, late in life, comes to realize a few simple truths: "She was a mother, a nurse. These were good things, sure and pure and constant. She need not be afraid."

Kevin Canfield is a writer and critic in New York City.

Mary Costello Photo by Martina Kenji
Mary Costello (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

KEVIN CANFIELD

More from Minnesota Star Tribune

See More
card image
Provided/Sahan Journal

Family members and a lawyer say they have been blocked from access to the bedside of Bonfilia Sanchez Dominguez, while her husband was detained and shipped to Texas within 24 hours.

card image