•••
In Minnesota, we don’t call each other “garbage.”
Patricia Raftery, Faribault, Minn.
•••
I was born here. I grew up here. I raised my kids here. In my teens, I remember the mass immigration of Hmong families to our state and saw the struggle to rebuild lives far away from where they were born. I’ve lived in other countries where I wasn’t a native citizen or had full command of the language. It came with challenges, but nothing like what the many waves of immigrants have felt that have come to Minnesota (and the U.S.). I have never fled a civil war.
If you believe deporting Somali Minnesotans is justified, you’re missing what the data actually says. Minnesota’s roughly 79,000 Somali Americans are among the state’s hardest-working low-income residents. More than 70% of working-age adults are employed, many in home-health care, manufacturing and small business. Their median household income — about $43,600 — is low, but that reflects new-arrival realities, large family sizes and credential barriers, not idleness. Poverty rates are high (around 36%), yet identical patterns appear among all Minnesotans living below 200% of the federal poverty line. Crime data is inconclusive since only race, not ethnicity, is reported, but it does not stand out as disproportionate to other lower-income communities. Benefit use (SNAP, Medicaid) mirrors eligibility, not abuse.
In short, these are taxpayers, parents, citizens and neighbors building stability under tougher odds. So if you still see deportation as deserved, you either don’t understand the numbers, don’t understand the refugee experience, or you’ve absorbed a distorted media narrative — and if you persist once the evidence is clear, that’s not policy judgment, that’s prejudice.