Readers Write: ICE arrested my friend, a U.S. citizen. This isn’t normal.

Letters on immigration enforcement, electronic waste and David Lynch.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
December 11, 2025 at 12:00AM
Activists confronted a group of Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers in the largely Somali neighborhood of Cedar-Riverside in Minneapolis on Dec. 9. (Mark Vancleave/The Associated Press)

Opinion editor’s note: Strib Voices publishes letters from readers online and in print each day. To contribute, click here.

•••

“Help! Help! Help!” It was hard to watch the video and even harder to listen to.

Yes, that was my friend Sue’s voice. Yes, she was being held to the ground in the snow by three masked figures with pistols and flak jackets while a fourth stands guard holding a long gun focused on a bystander filming Tuesday’s unfolding scene.

“It’s 6:24 a.m., on the cross street of North 21st Avenue, North Oliver Avenue,” says the man behind the camera.

Yes, that’s my friend Sue’s neighborhood. My friend Sue with the knit cap and furry-topped boots, mother of two, as kind as can be.

Now my friend Sue is being forced into a silver Dodge pickup, license number 056-KTH, as the cameraman narrates.

“Help! Help me! Help!” cries my friend Sue as whistles scream into the dark night lit up by front porch lights and the presence of concerned citizens willing to be temporarily disappeared by about eight unknown and unnamed secret police sent out on a predawn mission rather than have her immigrant neighbors disappeared for good.

It will take hours and pressure from local officials, Rep. Ilhan Omar and Sen. Tina Smith before my friend Sue is found and released. But it will take pressure from those that believe in free speech, and the rule of law, before the release of our beloved country.

David Leussler, Minneapolis

•••

My father was among the many of his generation who sacrificed to fight fascism. His army job was to train marksmen. He impressed upon us that you should never point a gun at a person unless you are prepared to kill them. Guns tend to provoke defensive violence and wield great harm, whether intended or not.

I wish he had trained those (assumed) Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents who pointed guns at Augsburg students Saturday (“College blasts ICE action on campus,” Dec. 9). Actually, we the people who pay these agents are prevented from knowing anything about them. Who trained them? What is their criminal history? We know from the ads that they are offered large sums of money and have quotas to fill. We know from experience that they do not follow our laws.

I witnessed an abduction in my neighborhood Thursday. All of a sudden several ordinary-looking cars, with unreadable license plates, clustered around an individual. He was being forced into a van. The only ID I saw was “federal police” written on the jacket back of one agent. I spoke with one of the agents and he was practically dancing in sadistic glee at the snatch.

Given our current circumstances, I have reason to believe that this was an ICE raid. But I wonder: When will other kidnappers follow suit? And after the fellow with whom I interacted is done with this job, what will keep him from using his human-hurting and lawbreaking skills again?

Amy Blumenshine, Minneapolis

•••

In the agricultural world there is a saying that when the harvest comes in, pick the low-hanging fruit first. Unfortunately, ICE agents have now adopted that philosophy while going after undocumented immigrants. They go to churches, schools, day cares, car washes, restaurants, courthouses and now, in San Diego, the centers where the spouses of U.S. military personnel check in. They are not going after the “worst of the worst” criminals as alleged by Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem. Less than 30% of those being detained have a criminal record but ICE continues to profile brown-skinned individuals so that they can make their quota.

Shame on this immoral and corrupt organization for their lack of humanitarian values when representing our country, which has always prided itself on being humane.

Jan McCarthy, Eden Prairie

•••

Around 1941, my grandmother, Susette, disappeared. Her daughter, my mother, Gerda, had escaped to America with the help of her father, director/cinematographer Karl Freund (“Metropolis,” “The Mummy,” “I Love Lucy,” etc.). We were told that Grandma had died of typhus in Ravensbrück Concentration Camp. Later, we discovered that she was murdered in a so-called “euthanasia center” at the Bernburg Mental Health Sanitarium where the Nazis had set aside the lower level to murder those “unfit to work.”

With the help of a skilled researcher, we were able to fill in many of the gaps, but we couldn’t determine how she got from her “Jewish apartment” initially to Ravensbrück before being transported to Bernburg. It was assumed that she was just picked up off the street. Eventually, we made a film about her fate (lostinberlinthemovie.com).

Until recently, I couldn’t understand how the average German citizen could have allowed this to happen. Witnessing the inhumane way ICE agents recently have “disappeared’ people off the streets has given me a new perspective. In this era of social media with ubiquitous and instant communication, even we do not know what has happened to many of the victims. I can only imagine in Germany with all communication controlled either through the national press, how the average citizen (even if well-intentioned) could feel powerless. None of us (irrespective of political persuasion) should allow this cruelty to ever become normalized as a way of enforcing immigration policy.

Rod Martel, Minneapolis

ELECTRONICS RECYCLING

Polluting practices revealed

Last month, the Basel Action Network (BAN) released a report that should alarm every Minnesotan, “Brokers of Shame: The New Tsunami of American E-Waste Exports to Asia.” It exposes a grim reality — some electronics Minnesotans dropped off for “safe recycling” were shipped to informal scrapyards in Southeast Asia, where underpaid workers dismantle them in hazardous, unregulated conditions. One of the largest companies implicated is Best Buy — a Minnesota-based retailer that has long marketed itself as a sustainability leader.

Best Buy claims to have responsibly recycled more than 2.7 billion pounds of electronics and promises that its recycling partners refurbish, repurpose or safely recycle components in ways that prioritize the environment and worker protections. The reality is that BAN’s investigation found that a significant portion of materials end up in Malaysia and other countries that lack necessary worker and environmental safeguards. Toxic chemicals, fire risks and environmental contamination are dumped onto communities that had no role in creating the problem.

Minnesota’s electronics waste laws haven’t been updated since 2007 — before smartphones, lithium batteries and the tidal wave of disposable electronics we rely on today.

Minnesota can change this. Strong Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) legislation for electronics and batteries would require companies like Best Buy to take full responsibility for the products they sell. That means financing convenient, statewide collection for all electronics and batteries, not just the ones easiest to recycle; tracking materials to ensure they are processed safely; and guaranteeing free, equitable access for all Minnesotans.

This letter was written by Marlise Riffel, president of Iron Range Partnership for Sustainability; Evan Mulholland, Healthy Communities Program Director at the Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy; and Kathleen Doran-Norton, a Rice County resident.

FILMS

David Lynch shows us the way

Thank you to Jeff Day for a wonderful travelogue chronicling David Lynch’s work and life in the Midwest (“A 1,200-mile journey into David Lynch’s Midwest,” Dec. 7). This probably wasn’t the point of the article, but Day may have captured the secret to bridging the divide in our politically fractured country through painting a portrait of Lynch’s time in the Midwest: Share your gifts widely, develop your spirituality and enjoy the doughnuts and coffee. If the late filmmaker could fall in love — and be loved — in both Los Angeles and Laurens, Iowa, maybe there’s hope for the rest of us.

Nick Hansen, Lakeville

about the writer

about the writer