Postgame thoughts on an eventful evening for Gophers

The first quarter against Michigan State set the tone for the game and possibly for the rest of Minnesota's season.

October 15, 2017 at 4:33PM
(The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Three observations from the Gophers' 30-27 loss to No. 21 Michigan State on Saturday night:

Minnesota's quarterback Demry Croft managed to complete a pass despite defensive pressure by Michigan State's defensive end Demetrius Cooper during the third quarter as the Gophers took on Michigan State at TCF Bank Stadium, Saturday, October 14, 2017 in Minneapolis, MN.    ]  ELIZABETH FLORES ' liz.flores@startribune.com
(Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The first quarter set the tone for a long and eventful evening

Though the Gophers trailed only 10-6 after the game's first 15 minutes, the mistakes they made haunted them the entire game and set the tone for a quarterback decision that could alter the rest of their season.

After Michigan State punter Jake Hartberger couldn't handle a snap and the Gophers' Jaylen Waters recovered the ball at the MSU 3-yard-line. On first down, Gophers quarterback Conor Rhoda dropped the shotgun snap and lost 4 yards. Two incompletions followed, and Minnesota had to settle for a field goal.

"First-and-goal at the 5-yard-lline, we need a touchdown,'' Gophers coach P.J. Fleck said. "You can't kick field goals against the No. 1 team in the country. We drop a snap and the whole playbook changes.''

Later in the quarter, Rhoda tried to hand the ball off to running back Shannon Brooks, who fumbled. Michigan State recovered at the Minnesota 8 and scored a touchdown two plays later for a 10-3 lead. Fleck said the handoff should not have happened.

Those two miscues prompted Fleck to replace Rhoda with Demry Croft, who led a fourth-quarter rally by throwing three TD passes. Fleck wouldn't say who will start against Illinois on Saturday, but one would figure that it will be Croft.

The run defense needs to improve

ADVERTISEMENT

Michigan State scorched the Gophers for 245 rushing yards on 50 carries, led by LJ Scott's 194 yards on 25 rushes. And if you throw out the 28-yard loss on Hartberger's fumbled punt snap, the Spartans averaged 5.6 yards per carry.

"We didn't hold the point very well and we didn't contain,'' Fleck said. "We've got to have guys in the secondary fly down and contain and sacrifice their bodies.''

That run defense still has big tests remaining in Michigan, which ranks fourth in the Big Ten at 185 rushing yards per game, and Wisconsin, which leads the conference at 263.8.

The Gophers' route to a bowl game is clear

At 3-3 overall and 0-3 in the Big Ten, the Gophers certainly won't be making any plans for playing in a big New Year's Day bowl. But they still can gain eligibility with three wins in their final six games. The path to that starts Saturday against Illinois, which lost 35-24 to Rutgers in the battle of Big Ten cellar-dwellers. Beating the Illini (2-4, 0-3) is a must for the Gophers. After that, they'll need two more wins. The most likely candidates are the Nov. 11 game against Nebraska (3-4, 2-2), which was pasted 56-14 by Ohio State in Lincoln on Saturday, and the Nov. 18 contest at Northwestern (3-3, 1-2). The tougher route for the Gophers would be upsetting one of their other three remaining opponents – at Iowa, at Michigan, vs. Wisconsin.

about the writer

about the writer

Randy Johnson

College football reporter

Randy Johnson covers University of Minnesota football and college football for the Minnesota Star Tribune, along with Gophers hockey and the Wild.

See Moreicon

More from Gophers

See More
card image
Claudia Staut/Gophers athletics

It’s the Tommies’ first tie with the Gophers after losing the first 23 meetings.

card image
card image