New video footage released from day of the fatal Brown University shooting

PROVIDENCE, R.I. — A new video from the day of the Brown University shooting that killed two students and injured nine others was released Monday, with city officials saying they had withheld other footage and redacted the most graphic, violent images to avoid harming victims.

''This was a difficult process to both maintain our commitment to transparency, to respond to requests from the media and the public's right to know exactly what happened, but also balancing what we know are potential, really serious downside effects of releasing some of this information,'' Providence Mayor Brett Smiley said at a news conference.

News outlets across the U.S. and other countries had been requesting body camera footage, audio clips and other public records shortly after the shooting took place in mid-December.

Material shows police response to the shooting

The newly released material includes audio of a campus police officer calling city police at 4:07 p.m. ''This is Brown police. We have confirmed gunshots at 184 Hope Street,'' the officer said. ''We do have a victim but we do not know where they are.''

Four minutes later, campus police called back with an update: ''We have a suspect description, wearing all black and a ski mask, unknown travel direction.''

Separately, the city released roughly 20 minutes of body camera footage of the officer in charge of the initial response to the shooting. The heavily redacted footage shows a chaotic and confusing scene of officers not knowing if the shooter was still in the building and attempts to quickly find a safe spot to send the students evacuated from the building. Scattered backpacks, gloves and other items can be seen as officers scour the building looking for a possible shooter and victims.

He later cautions other officers, ''Shooter might still be in the building, so use caution alright.''

Long portions of the video are either blacked out or with the audio redacted. The video is often blocked by the officer's arms in front of the camera. Officials defended their decision, made in consultation with city lawyers, to release only one video, saying it offered the most ''comprehensive'' view. Smiley argued that releasing more videos would not answer the harder question of why the shooter chose to attack the university.

''Why did this person do this? None of those videos are going to answer that question. None of them,'' Smiley said.

Other audio captures officers describing a possible sighting of the shooter on the second floor of another building and a report of a suspect being taken into custody. That person turned out to be a maintenance worker. It's unclear when officers realized they had the wrong person in custody, but within minutes, one officer instructs them ''We're gonna work on the premise that that's not him. We're gonna conduct a secondary search.''

The city released those records Monday, saying they waited at the request of the victims′ families until after a memorial service was held the previous week on Brown's campus. Smiley said he had spoken to the victims and their families in recent days.

Details of the shooting

On Dec. 13, gunman Claudio Neves Valente, 48, entered a study session in a Brown academic building and opened fire on students, killing 19-year-old sophomore Ella Cook and 18-year-old freshman MukhammadAziz Umurzokov and wounding nine others.

A newly released police incident report reiterated the emotional moments law enforcement had previously shared about hospitalized victims responding to photos of the suspected shooter.

One victim ''quickly froze, physically pushed back'' and began crying and shaking as she confirmed the image matched the person who shot her. Another victim ''took a deep breath, shut his eyes, changed his breathing pattern and confirmed that the shooter he saw in the hallway appeared to be the person in the photos presented.''

Authorities say Neves Valente, who had been a graduate student at Brown studying physics during the 2000-01 school year, also fatally shot Massachusetts Institute of Technology professor Nuno F.G. Loureiro at Loureiro's Boston-area home.

The Justice Department has since said Neves Valente planned the attack for years and left behind videos in which he confessed to the killings but gave no motive. The FBI recovered the electronic device containing the series of videos during a search of the storage facility where Neves Valente's body was found.

___