Minnesota Women's March keeps eyes on future amid anti-Semitism controversy

Some former supporters will boycott the rally over remarks by national leaders.

January 18, 2019 at 4:59AM
A young girl stood front and center at the front of the procession from St. Paul College to the State Capitol for the noon rally. ] ANTHONY SOUFFLE • anthony.souffle@startribune.com Women's activists and supporters gathered at St. Paul College then marched to the State Capitol for a noon rally Saturday, Jan. 21, 2017 for a local version of the big national D.C. women's march. ORG XMIT: MIN1701211543353332
A young girl stood front and center at the front of the procession from St. Paul College to the State Capitol for the 2017 rally. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

A sea of pink hats will once a­gain de­scend on the State Capitol on Sat­ur­day as Min­ne­so­tans gather to pro­mote e­qual rights and pro­gres­sive caus­es at the third annu­al Women's March.

The Minnesota rally, part of a na­tion­al "Women's Wave" day of ac­tion, comes at a time of fresh scru­ti­ny for the move­ment, which sprung up in re­sponse to Pres­i­dent Don­ald Trump's e­lec­tion.

Women's March Inc., the nonprofit spear­head­ing the na­tion­al move­ment, is weathering crit­i­cism amid claims of mis­man­age­ment and that several of its high-pro­file co-chairs have ex­press­ed or en­dorsed anti-Se­mit­ic views.

Some local activists want Women's March Min­ne­so­ta to con­demn the leaders or of­fi­cial­ly sever ties with the na­tion­al arm, as more than a doz­en local chap­ters have done. The controversy is already dampening enthusiasm among some past supporters.

Su­san Minsberg said the 2017 march in­spired her to go be­yond her own po­lit­i­cal ac­tiv­ism. But she is sitting out this year af­ter watch­ing a seg­ment on "The View" in which na­tion­al Women's March co-President Tamika Mallory de­clined to con­demn past hate­ful re­marks by Na­tion of Islam founder Louis Farrakhan.

"I think we need to call her out, but they won't call her out," said Minsberg, who is Jew­ish. "They say it's not our job, but whose job is it?"

Or­gan­iz­ers of this year's Min­ne­so­ta march, which is co­or­di­nat­ed by a local non­prof­it that op­er­ates in­de­pend­ent­ly of the na­tion­al group, say they re­main fo­cused on "cele­brat­ing women's lead­er­ship and the suc­cess of get­ting women elect­ed" in 2019.

"We're build­ing on that mo­men­tum and com­muni­ty spir­it from when ev­er­y­one [first] came to­gether," said Jammi Han­sen Blair, chairwoman of Women's March Min­ne­so­ta. "We re­al­ly think that we have been part of this broad­er move­ment in get­ting peo­ple more ac­tive and par­tici­pat­ing in their gov­ern­ment."

The first Women's March, held the day af­ter Trump's in­au­gu­ra­tion, in­spired a wave of po­lit­i­cal ac­tiv­ism and en­er­gy a­mong fe­male can­di­dates and voters on the left. Millions turned out for march­es across the coun­try, mak­ing the 2017 gath­er­ing one of the larg­est pro­tests in U.S. his­to­ry. But the recent con­tro­ver­sy has dominated in the weeks lead­ing up to the march­es.

Promi­nent form­er back­ers, in­clud­ing the Democratic National Committee, the Southern Pov­er­ty Law Center and EMILY's List, severed ties with the na­tion­al march.

Locally, high-pro­file groups in­clud­ing Education Min­ne­so­ta, NAACP Minneapolis and the local Planned Par­ent­hood chap­ter re­main as spon­sors.

This year's event will lack some of the political firepower of past marches.

Just one mem­ber of the state's con­gres­sion­al del­e­ga­tion, Rep. Ilhan Omar, is sched­uled to ad­dress the crowd. Staff for sev­er­al oth­er Democratic of­fi­cials, in­clud­ing U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar, Lt. Gov. Peg­gy Flan­a­gan and House Speaker Me­lis­sa Hortman, said they will be on the Iron Range attending the funeral for former DFL legislator Tom Rukavina.

Han­sen Blair is trying to distance the local march from the national controversy, say­ing local lead­ers are "dis­ap­point­ed that these con­ver­sa­tions have tak­en away from the im­port­ant work that's be­ing done." She add­ed that local lead­er­ship will "be re-ev­alu­at­ing who we are af­fili­at­ed with" mov­ing for­ward but did not pro­vide a timeline. The chapter has also issued several statements condemning bigoted and hateful speech.

Ra­chael Jo­seph, an ad­vo­cate for gun vi­o­lence sur­viv­ors, said that as a Jew­ish woman, she de­cid­ed to at­tend this year's march af­ter con­ver­sations with local ac­tiv­ists.

"What I ap­pre­ci­ate the most is they are will­ing to have the dia­logue," said Jo­seph of Min­ne­ap­olis. "They em­brace dis­sent­ing voic­es, hear peo­ple out and they grow and change from that."

But some Republicans say local organizers are not seizing the moment to express opposition to anti-Semitic views.

"It's deep­ly con­cern­ing the Min­ne­so­ta Women's March re­fuses to de­nounce the ob­vi­ous­ly anti-Se­mit­ic na­tion­al Women's March Inc. and is still af­fili­at­ed with this rac­ist or­gan­i­za­tion," said Sen. Mi­chelle Benson, R-Ham Lake.

Han­sen Blair urged current and former supporters to embrace the larger mission. "Un­less we re­al­ly do come to­gether, real change doesn't get made," she said.

Torey Van Oot • 651-925-5049

about the writer

about the writer

Torey Van Oot

Politics and Government

Torey Van Oot reports on Minnesota politics and government for the Star Tribune.

See Moreicon

More from No Section

See More

Peek inside homes for sale in the Twin Cities area.

card image