Analysis: Loons’ victory at San Diego is the latest sign of a special season

Minnesota United manager Eric Ramsay said his players are full of confidence after outlasting the first-place team in the Western Conference late Saturday.

For the Minnesota Star Tribune
September 14, 2025 at 11:17PM
Loons coach Eric Ramsay won the tactical matchup Saturday night against a San Diego team that plays a very different style than his club. (Carlos Gonzalez/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

When the dust settled from Minnesota United’s 3-1 victory at San Diego late Saturday night, the Loons were left in a place they have simply never been at this point of the season.

The victory meant the Loons set a club record for points in a season, with 54. It also put them squarely in the race for the top seed in the Western Conference. They now trail San Diego by only two points with four games to play — though Vancouver, which hammered Philadelphia 7-0 on Saturday night, is two points back of the Loons and has two games in hand.

And for the true dreamers, Minnesota is now only three points back of Philadelphia for the lead in the Supporters’ Shield race. The first tiebreaker is victories, though, and the Loons, with 15, are behind just about every other top team in that regard, something coach Eric Ramsay was quick to point out after the game. “I think it’s going to be tough,” he said.

Given, though, that the Loons have never finished within 19 points of the Supporters’ Shield winner in a full season, being three points back with four games to play feels like a significant accomplishment.

“We’ve got a U.S. [Open] Cup semifinal [Wednesday night vs. Austin], and we’ve got a group that’s in a really good place with a lot of confidence,” Ramsay said. “I couldn’t ask for much more at this point.”

Defensive success ‘not by luck’

Look purely at the numbers, and it was a true smash-and-grab victory. San Diego took seven shots and forced two excellent saves out of goalkeeper Dayne St. Clair before the Loons had even come close to taking a shot of their own. Before the sequence that led to the game’s first goal in the 73rd minute, Minnesota’s only attempted shot was a first-half glancing header from Robin Lod that didn’t come near the net.

But don’t try to tell Ramsay that his team blindly stumbled into three points.

“I think the game spanned out roughly as you would expect in terms of the balance and the look and feel of the game,” he said. “We’ve won in the way that we’ve won a lot of games this year. And it’s not by coincidence. We’ve picked up incredibly good results on the road against some very, very good teams. And that is by design, and certainly not by luck.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The Loons’ road record is inarguable. They got a 0-0 draw at Vancouver — and ask league-leading Philadelphia how difficult it is to play on the road against the Whitecaps. They won at San Diego and Seattle. They won at Real Salt Lake, which they had never done before in MLS.

So yes, San Diego outshot the Loons 28-6 and St. Clair made 12 saves. But the Loons are comfortable with that bend-but-don’t break style, and it’s working for them.

Ramsay pointed out that his team might have given up 50-plus crosses against Real Salt Lake, for example, but defended them all.

“We’re a very good team in that sense; I’ve not seen much better,” he said. “I’ve really enjoyed coaching that side of the game with this team because we, as the season has gone on, have really settled into our way of playing. I think the players feel like it suits them really well. I think it brings the best out in a lot of their qualities. In the second half, we were able to show that real resilience from a defensive perspective.”

A matchup for the purists

You won’t get much more of a contrast between two teams in MLS as you do with Minnesota and San Diego. SDFC has poured all of its resources into a ball-on-the-ground, passing team. The Loons are happy to defend, go long, rely on set pieces.

It was clear that Ramsay relished the challenge. “I think they’re very high-level games from a tactical perspective,” he said. “Both coaches, I would say, are relatively pragmatic in the sense that they’re matching style to player profiles or we’re matching styles to player profiles. And I think what you get is a really interesting game.”

Both teams made adjustments as Saturday’s game went on; Ramsay credited his team’s changes for resetting the game around the 15- or 20-minute mark — though as any good tactical schemer would, he refused to detail exactly what those changes were. Around that time, though, San Diego midfielders Jeppe Tverskov and Onni Valakari stopped having the luxury of time on the ball in the center of the field, which made things harder for the home team.

“I think if you’re a football purist and you’re watching it from the perspective of tactics, strategies, matchups, changes as the game goes on, I think it’s a really good game and I’ve enjoyed it and obviously I’ve enjoyed it more tonight because we won the game,” Ramsay said. “Certainly, over the course of 180 minutes we played [in the two games between the teams this year], I think it’s been MLS at its very best.”

Dayne St. Clair was kept busy Sunday night at San Diego, but the Loons goalkeeper made 12 saves and nearly posted a shutout before giving up a harmless goal in the waning moments. (Minnesota United)
about the writer

about the writer

Jon Marthaler

Freelance

Jon Marthaler has been covering Minnesota soccer for more than 15 years, all the way back to the Minnesota Thunder.

See Moreicon

More from Loons

See More
card image
card image