Lori Sturdevant: What's so special about $40 billion?

May 13, 2015 at 6:57PM

The value of the GOP's preferred spending ceiling is hard to measure.

Pop quiz: How big is the state's biennial budget?

I bet your answer was "I don't know."

Don't count yourself ill-informed. I'll venture that most attentive citizens aren't such devoted students of the state's fiscal condition that they can summon such statistics to mind without the aid of a search engine.

Yet by the way House Republicans reportedly are insisting in budget-setting talks this week that the 2016-17 state budget ought not exceed $40 billion, one might think they believe that every Minnesota voter can recite such numbers by heart.

If those reports are true, I expect to see "$40 billion and no more" buttons popping up on GOP lapels — just as four years ago, pennies appeared on lapels to signify "not a penny more" than $34 billion for 2012-13.

That year's budget wound up at $35.5 billion, and took a government shutdown to achieve. This year, Gov. Mark Dayton proposed a budget for the 2016-17 biennium of $42.8 billion. Republicans say that's too much growth.

But to hold their proposed spending below $40 billion, Republicans have employed a variety of convoluted moves, including shifting some spending out of the general fund, rescheduling some spending to occur before the new biennium begins, and assuming gains from proposed spending cuts far in excess of what nonpartisan fiscal analysts say can be attained. Those maneuvers are hard to convince DFL budget negotiators to accept.

I'm left puzzling over the $40 billion ceiling's political value. It's a sum that's difficult for voters to evaluate. One might recall that state spending was artificially suppressed during the Great Recession by issuing IOUs to school districts that at one point reached $2.7 billion. During the same period spending on human services, higher education, the courts and more was squeezed to a point of discomfort for many Minnesotans. And some customary state responsibilities were temporarily covered by non-recurring federal stimulus dollars.

Dayton's budget is predicated on his assessment that Minnesotans don't want to live with recession-era constraints forever. The GOP's $40 billion ceiling would continue some of the squeeze Dayton and Senate DFLers want to ease.

LORI STURDEVANT

about the writer

about the writer

Lori Sturdevant

Columnist

Lori Sturdevant is a retired Star Tribune editorial writer and columnist. She was a journalist at the Star Tribune for 43 years and an Editorial Board member for 26 years. She is also the author or editor of 13 books about notable Minnesotans. 

See Moreicon

More from Commentaries

See More
card image
Alex Kormann/The Minnesota Star Tribune

The administration’s justifications keep changing. The focus on county jails is just one of the latest.

card image
card image