Jim Kaat should be in the Hall of Fame. He won 261 games in 18 seasons as a starting pitcher, then re-invented himself for five seasons and 22 more victories as an effective lefthanded reliever.
He continues to hold the record for winning 16 consecutive Gold Gloves (1962-1977) as a fielder. He was a worthy hitter, finishing his career with 16 home runs and 106 RBI.
He was 25-13 and pitched 304 2/3 innings for the Twins in 1966. That would have earned him a Cy Young Award, except it was the final year when a single Cy Young covered both leagues, and Sandy Koufax went 27-9 with a 1.73 ERA in his last season with the Dodgers.
Even if the baseball writers were correct in failing to elect Kaat in his 15 years on the players ballot, he assuredly deserves a place in the Cooperstown, N.Y., museum as a winner of the Ford Frick Award for baseball broadcasting.
Kaat did both analysis and play-by-play in 21 years on television, with the Twins, with CBS, and for his final 13 seasons (1994-2006) with the Yankees. There never has been a broadcaster to tell you more about the game than Kaat, and there's never been a former player with less need to talk about himself during a broadcast.
The Yankees rewarded Kaat for his excellence with generous pay, but they were unable to talk him out of retirement after the 2006 season. He went home to Stuart, Fla., and started making plans with his wife, Mary Ann, to see the country in their Itasca-Meridian model Winnebago.
"We left Florida at the end of May and didn't get back until the middle of November," Kaat said. "We traveled 10,400 miles through 27 states, with stops at 60 different golf courses and twice as many art galleries.
"Mary Ann doesn't golf, so she brushes the cats while I'm playing golf, and then I pay her back by visiting art galleries.