Economists concerned about slowing productivity have spent the past decade hotly debating the value of free digital services such as Google's web search and Amazon's online store. Those online services have proved their worth during the pandemic.
And COVID-19 may ultimately push our society to learn new ways of using digital technologies that accelerate productivity growth.
Over the past year I've been occasionally bombarded with tweets casting doubt on the value of software companies. The allegation that online services didn't help with the pandemic came on top of a pre-existing concern — prevalent among some economists, as well as critics of the technology industry — that these services add little to the real economy.
But let's do a scary little thought experiment. Try to imagine what 2020 would have been like without Google, Amazon, Zoom, Slack or any of the other online services. It's pretty terrifying.
First, because Amazon wouldn't have existed (nor would any other online marketplace), everyone would have had to buy everything in physical stores. Imagine the lines stretching around the block as impatient mask-wearing crowds stood 6 feet apart, waiting hours for the chance to buy some toilet paper or soap.
Not only would this have been an incredible inconvenience, it also would have increased the risk of infection. And because many people would probably have delayed their purchases of furniture and appliances until after the pandemic, the economy would have suffered even more.
People would also have had to go in to their offices. With no Zoom, Slack or other remote management tools, companies that currently have their employees working from home would have had to either halt operations — hurting the economy even more grievously — or find some way to bring them in.
Workers congregating in offices would have spread the disease, especially before everyone realized the importance of ventilation and the fact that 6 feet of distancing isn't enough.
Of course, on-site work was still the reality for many essential front-line workers, but through remote work, at least some Americans managed to avoid it, helping sustain much of the economy.
And without online communication tools that allow you to see the faces of friends and family and hear their voices, imagine how much lonelier people would have been during social distancing.
Finally, imagine looking for information about COVID without Google, Facebook and other disseminators of free online news. People would have been glued to their television screens, waiting for updates from the government — and that would have meant being forced to listen to former President Donald Trump's fire hose of misinformation. It would have taken the public much longer to realize that masks actually helped reduce the spread of the virus.
So when you think about it, it's pretty incredible that these online services were invented just in time for a once-in-a-century pandemic. Though some have pooh-poohed Silicon Valley's usefulness in the era of COVID, the advent of these software companies utterly transformed America's ability to weather a plague.
So we should think more carefully about the value of free digital services. In recent decades, academics have debated whether products that are free to users — Google, Facebook, the basic versions of Amazon and Zoom and Slack — create more economic value than the official numbers record. Productivity growth has been slowing down in the last decade and a half, which leads many people to ask how that can happen when we have all this fabulous innovation.
But productivity measurements depend on the price people pay for things; if people don't have to pay, there may be value creation that the statistics miss.
Until now, those who argue that online services don't create a lot of hidden value have had the upper hand in the debate. Economist Chad Syverson, for example, has argued convincingly that digital services aren't creating huge amounts of unmeasured value.
But Syverson's analysis is limited to normal times. The U.S.'s reliance on online services to get it through the pandemic might be one reason its economy suffered less than others, and is now on track to bounce back faster than most.
Of course, just how much digital services contributed to America's outperformance is a question that needs research to answer. But it illustrates the principle that we can't rely only on normal times to judge the value of innovations. Sometimes technologies act as insurance policies — a way of backstopping society against disaster.
What's more, the pandemic might dramatically increase the productivity of digital services going forward. In previous waves of innovation, it often took a long time for society to figure out how to employ the new technologies in a useful way.
For example, electricity didn't immediately make factories much more efficient. It wasn't until after businesspeople learned how to reorganize their assembly lines around small electric motors that manufacturing productivity surged.
Another example is the computer; economist Robert Solow declared in 1987 that "you can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics." But just a few years later computerization was powering the boom of the 1990s.
In a similar way, the social distancing that COVID-19 forced on society might be teaching us how to use online services in a more productive way. Remote work could allow companies to distribute their workforces to low-cost locations, and could nudge them to reevaluate the necessity of many meetings and routine office tasks. A shift from brick-and-mortar business to e-commerce might cause supply chains to become less fragmented.
So in addition to creating resiliency against COVID, Silicon Valley's digital service products might ultimately allow a transformation of our economy that was difficult to envision in the pre-pandemic days.
Software might be only beginning to show its worth.