Advertisement

High notes and low notes on 'Idol'

May 22, 2012 at 10:13PM
American Idol contestant Jessica Sanchez performs in front of the judges.
American Idol contestant Jessica Sanchez performs in front of the judges. (Colleen Kelly — ASSOCIATED PRESS/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Jeff Alexander watches "American Idol" so you don't have to. When he's not writing proposals for a Twin Cities health-care company, he provides snarky analysis of the show at the website Television Without Pity. As finalists Jessica Sanchez and Phillip Phillips vie for the top spot Tuesday and Wednesday, Alexander talked to TV critic Neal Justin about what stood out this year.

WHO GOT ROBBED

"Probably Elise Testone. She had a really good voice, but seemed to have trouble finding a fan base. She picked a couple songs that matched her voice well, like Led Zeppelin's 'Whole Lotta Love,' but other times she missed the boat. She was the oldest of the contestants, and that can make it tricky. I think she would have done better in another kind of competition."

MOST EMBARRASSING JUDGE

"They're all embarrassing in their way. Randy [Jackson] keeps repeating himself. Jennifer [Lopez] just babbles on. But Steven Tyler is the real wild card. He says things like, 'If you're facing the sun, the shadows are behind you.' Last week, he told Phillip Phillips that he should get used to fame, because you never will.' Huh?"

MOST OVERRATED FINALIST

"Probably Phil [Phillips]. I know he's popular, but the shtick he does is very narrow. I like him fine, but I don't know if he's a top-three singer."

BEST SINGLE PERFORMANCE

Advertisement
Advertisement

"Phil's performance of Damien Rice's 'Volcano' was really good. It was just very raw and stripped down, just him, one other musician and a backup singer. Not all Dave Matthews-y, like he can be."

WHOM HE'S ROOTING FOR IN THE FINAL

"Jessica [Sanchez] is the most technically accomplished singer, so I guess it would be her. Quite frankly, I'm not all that invested in the competition. After all these months of performing, you kind of get tired of all of them."

about the writer

about the writer

Neal Justin

Critic / Reporter

Neal Justin is the pop-culture critic, covering how Minnesotans spend their entertainment time. He also reviews stand-up comedy. Justin previously served as TV and music critic for the paper. He is the co-founder of JCamp, a non-profit program for high-school journalists, and works on many fronts to further diversity in newsrooms.

See Moreicon

More from Minnesota Star Tribune

See More
In this photo taken Monday, March 6, 2017, in San Francisco, released confidential files by The University of California of a sexual misconduct case, like this one against UC Santa Cruz Latin Studies professor Hector Perla is shown. Perla was accused of raping a student during a wine-tasting outing in June 2015. Some of the files are so heavily redacted that on many pages no words are visible. Perla is one of 113 UC employees found to have violated the system's sexual misconduct policies in rece

We respect the desire of some tipsters to remain anonymous, and have put in place ways to contact reporters and editors to ensure the communication will be private and secure.

Advertisement
Advertisement

To leave a comment, .

Advertisement