'Heidi Chronicles' is more time capsule than throwback

REVIEW: Wendy Wasserstein's most celebrated play feels a bit dated, from the 1960s through the Reagan era.

September 25, 2014 at 8:31PM
Kate Wetherhead (Heidi Holland) keeps a skeptical and fearful distance from life in Wendy Wasserstein’s “The Heidi Chronicles” at the Guthrie Theater.
Kate Wetherhead (Heidi Holland) keeps a skeptical and fearful distance from life in Wendy Wasserstein’s “The Heidi Chronicles” at the Guthrie Theater. (Vince Tuss/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Dig those bell bottoms — big, elephant bell bottoms with the waist cut up around the rib cage and yards of denim washed to baby blue. Can you believe people once bought these jeans not as a joke but because they were chic?

Heidi Holland wears a pair for a while as she chronicles her weary path from 1965 high school grad to late '80s art historian. She was stylish then, just as her angsty uncertainty about her life fit the zeitgeist. We had the luxury of burrowing into our small lives — what they call today first-world problems.

Bell bottoms such as Heidi wore are not timeless and neither, unfortunately, are the circumstances and characters in Wendy Wasserstein's "The Heidi Chronicles," which opened Friday at the Guthrie Theater.

Perhaps nostalgia governed our expectations that this Pulitzer and Tony winner from 1989 would reveal eternal truths about fulfillment (or lack thereof) through Heidi's commentary on her life and times. Rather, the realization creeps up during director Leigh Silverman's flat production that these people are temporal and unlikable. Scoop Rosenbaum has an impossible ego; Peter Patrone is precious and Heidi herself is never happy.

That, of course, was Wasserstein's intention — to show how this shy, bookish young woman never quite found the sweet spot of contentment in an era when women were urged to "have it all."

Her friends made firm choices — to torch their undergarments and steep themselves in a women's collective, to be a mother and wife, or to feed at the trough of soulless success. Whiny Heidi only smiles at them — a smile that judges with its passive color of disappointment.

Actor Kate Wetherhead plays Heidi much as the character sees herself — "a highly informed spectator." She is intelligent, friendly, thoughtful and fearful about sticking her toe into the waters of life.

Heidi watches in fear as her friend Susan (Tracey Maloney) lusts for a guy who can smoke a cigarette and twist his hips at the same time. Her closest friendship with a man is platonic: Peter (Zach Shaffer) wants to dance when he's a little tipsy and to save the world when he's earnest. His sexual orientation, though, limits the relationship. Scoop (Ben Graney), who woos Heidi at a Gene McCarthy rally with his intelligence and resourcefulness, is a cad who rarely examines his philandering, self-important life.

At least those three are plunging forward — blindly on occasion — into the unkown. Wetherhead's Heidi keeps uncertainty at arm's length. Is this wisdom or the fear of making a mistake? Perhaps those are two sides of the same coin and we admire the sensibility of caution. That doesn't make for riveting drama. Heidi has chums, career, opportunities, disappointments. She's not feeling totally complete but hey, welcome to the world, my friend.

The cheap fun of this play is watching the stereotypes Wasserstein props up along Heidi's journey: Mo Perry portrays a profane feminist clad in a military shirt (the costumes by Clint Ramos perfectly express character). Stacia Rice is a glittering stick of eye candy as the bubble-headed host of a talk show.

Wasserstein's snapshot of a woman's life, from 25 years ago, remains an important intellectual inquiry of its time. Our cynicism, the world's volatility, the din of every person's belief in their own righteousness (Facebooked lately?) leaves us, sadly, with remembrances of oddball hairstyles and fashions.

Graydon Royce • graydon.royce@startribune.com

085: Stacia Rice (April), Ben Graney (Scoop Rosenbaum), Kate Wetherhead (Heidi Holland) and Zach Shaffer (Peter Patrone) in The Heidi Chronicles by Wendy Wasserstein. Directed by Leigh Silverman, set and costume design by Clint Ramos, lighting design by Eric Southern, sound design by Bart Fasbender. September 13 - October 26, 2014 on the Wurtele Thrust Stage at the Guthrie Theater, Minneapolis. Photo by Joan Marcus. The Heidi Chronicles September 13 - October 26, 2014 on the Wurtele Thrust Stage
Stacia Rice plays a TV host for Scoop (Ben Graney), Heidi (Kate Wetherhead) and Peter (Zach Shaffer) in “The Heidi Chronicles.” Photo by Joan Marcus (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Graydon Royce, Star Tribune

More from Minnesota Star Tribune

See More
card image
Provided/Sahan Journal

Family members and a lawyer say they have been blocked from access to the bedside of Bonfilia Sanchez Dominguez, while her husband was detained and shipped to Texas within 24 hours.

card image