There are plenty of reasons to get hooked on these thick, palm-sized treats. They're crispy and deeply golden on the outside, and tender and chewy on the inside, like any self-respecting Toll House-er should be. They're packed with rich, flavorful chocolate and front-loaded with copious amounts of rich butter. They're tailor-made for a tall glass of cold milk. Oh, and they're only a buck.

Runner-up: Brownies at Wilde Roast Café